11. THE SHAMBHALA MYTH AND THE WEST
The spread of the Shambhala myth and the Kalachakra
Tantra in the West has a history of its own. It does definitely not
first begin with the expulsion of the lamas from Tibet (in 1959) and their
diaspora across the whole world, but rather commences at the beginning of
the twentieth century in Russia with the religious political activity of an
ethnic Buriat by the name of Agvan Dorjiev.
The Shambhala missionary Agvan Dorjiev
Even in his youth, Agvan Dorjiev
(1854–1938), who trained as a monk in Tibet, was already a very promising
individual. For this reason he was as a young man entrusted with caring for
the Thirteenth Dalai Lama. The duties of the Buriat included among other
things the ritual cleansing of the body and bedroom of the god-king, which
implies quite an intimate degree of contact. Later he was to be at times
the closest political adviser of His Holiness.
Dorjiev was convinced that the union of
Tibet with Russia would provide the Highlands with an extremely favorable
future, and was likewise able to convince the hierarch upon the Lion Throne
of the merits of his political vision for a number of years. He thus
advanced to the post of Tibetan envoy in St. Petersburg and at the Russian
court. His work in the capital was extremely active and varied. In 1898 he
had his first audience with Tsar Nicholas II, which was supposed to be
followed by others. The Russian government was opening up with greater
tolerance towards the Asian minorities among whom the Buriats were also to
be counted, and was attempting to integrate them more into the Empire
whilst still respecting their religious and cultural autonomy, instead of
missionizing them as they had still done at the outset of the 19th century.
Even as a boy, Nicholas II had been
fascinated by Tibet and the “yellow pontiff” from Lhasa. The famous
explorer, Nikolai Przhevalsky, introduced the 13-year-old Tsarevitch to the
history and geopolitics of Central Asia. Przhevalsky described the Dalai
Lama as a „powerful Oriental pope with dominion over some 250 million
Asiatic souls” and believed that a Russian influence in Tibet would lead to
control of the entire continent and that this must be the first goal of
Tsarist foreign policy (Schimmelpennink, 1994, p. 16). Prince Esper Esperovich Ukhtomsky,
influential at court and deeply impressed by the Buddhist teachings, also
dreamed of a greater Asian Empire under the leadership of the “White Tsars”.
Since the end of the 19th century
Buddhism had become a real fashion among the Russian high society,
comparable only to what is currently happening in Hollywood, where more and
more stars profess to the doctrine of the Dalai Lama. It was considered
stylish to appeal to Russia’s Asiatic inheritance and to invoke the
Mongolian blood which flowed in the veins of every Russian with emotional
phrases. The poet, Vladimir Solovjov declaimed, “Pan-Mongolism — this word:
barbaric, yes! Yet a sweet sound” (Block, n.d., p. 247).
Agvan Dorjiev
The mysto-political influences upon the
court of the Tsar of the naïve demonic village magician, Rasputin, are
common knowledge. Yet the power-political intrigues of an intelligent Asian
doctor by the name of Peter Badmajev ought to have been of far greater
consequence. Like Dorjiev, whom he knew well, he was a Buriat and
originally a Buddhist, but he had then converted to Russian Orthodox. His
change of faith was never really bought by those around him, who frequented
him above all as a mighty shaman that was “supposed to be initiated into
all the secrets of Asia” (Golowin, 1977, p. 219).
Badmajev was head of the most famous
private hospital in St. Petersburg. There the cabinet lists for the
respective members of government were put together under his direction. R.
Fülöp-Miller has vividly described the doctor’s power-political activities:
“In the course of time medicine and politics, ministerial appointments and
'lotus essences' became more and more mingled, and a fantastic political
magic character arose, which emanated from Badmajev’s sanatorium and
determined the fate of all Russia. The miracle-working doctor owed this
influence especially to his successful medical-political treatment of the
Tsar. ... Badmajev’s mixtures, potions, and powders brewed from mysterious
herbs from the steppes served not just to remedy patient’s metabolic
disturbances; anyone who took these medicaments ensured himself an
important office in the state at the same time” (Fülöp-Miller, 1927, pp. 112,
148). For this “wise and crafty Asian” too, the guiding idea was the
establishment of an Asian empire with the “White Tsar” at its helm.
In this overheated pro-Asian climate,
Dorjiev believed, probably somewhat rashly, that the Tsar had a genuine
personal interest in being initiated into the secrets of Buddhism. The
Buriat’s goal was to establish a mchod-yon
relationship between Nicholas II and the god-king from Lhasa, that is,
Russian state patronage of Lamaism. Hence a trip to Russia by the Dalai
Lama was prepared which, however, never eventuated.
Bolshevik Buddhism
One would think that Dorjiev had a
compassionate heart for the tragic fate of the Tsarist family. At least,
Nicholas II had supported him and the Thirteenth Dalai Lama had even declared
the Russian heir to the throne to be a Bodhisattva because a number of
attempts to give him a Christian baptism mysteriously failed. At Dorjiev’s
behest, pictures of the Romanovs adorned the Buddhist temple in St.
Petersburg.
Hence, it is extremely surprising that
the Buriat greeted the Russian October Revolution and the seizure of power
by the Bolsheviks with great emotion. What stood behind this about-face, a
change of attitude or understandable opportunism? More likely the former,
then at the outset of the twenties Dorjiev, along with many famous Russian
orientalists, was convinced that Communism and Buddhism were compatible. He
publicly proclaimed that the teaching of Shakyamuni was an “atheistic
religion” and that it would be wrong to describe it as “unscientific”. Men
in his immediate neighborhood even went so far as to celebrate the
historical Buddha as the original founder of Communism and to glorify Lenin
as an incarnation of the Enlightened One. There are reliable rumors that
Dorjiev and Lenin had met.
Initially the Bolsheviks appreciated
such currying of favor and made use of it to win Buddhist Russians over to
their ideas. Already in 1919, the second year of the Revolution, an
exhibition of Buddhist art was permitted and encouraged amidst extreme
social turmoil. The teachings of Shakyamuni lived through a golden era,
lectures about the Sutras were held, numerous Buddhist books were
published, contacts were established with Mongolian and Tibetan scholars.
Even the ideas of pan-Mongolism were reawakened and people began to dream
of blood-filled scenes. In the same year, in his famous poem of hate Die Skythen [The Scythians],
Alexander Block prophesied the fall of Europe through the combined assault
of the Russians and the Mongolians. In it we can read that
We shall see through the
slits of our eyes
How the Huns fight over
your flesh,
How your cities collapse
And your horses graze
between the ruins.
(Block, n.d., p. 249)
Even the Soviet Union’s highest-ranking
cultural official of the time, Anatoli Vassilievich Lunacharski, praised
Asia as a pure source of inexhaustible reserves of strength: “We need the
Revolution to toss aside the power of the bourgeoisie and the power of
rationality at the same time so as to regain the great power of elementary
life, so as to dissolve the world in the real music of intense being. We
respect and honor Asia as an area which until now draws its life energy
from exactly these right sources and which is not poisoned by European reason”
(Trotzkij, 1968, p. 55).
Yet the Buddhist, pan-Asian El Dorado
of Leningrad transformed itself in 1929 into a hell, as the Stalinist
secret service began with a campaign to eradicate all religious currents.
Some years later Dorjiev was arrested as a counterrevolutionary and then
put on trial for treason and terrorism. On January 29, 1938 the “friend of
the Dalai Lama” died in a prison hospital.
The Kalachakra temple in
St. Petersburg
There is a simple reason for Dorjiev’s
enthusiasm for Russia. He was convinced that the Kalachakra system and the Shambhala
myth had their origins in the Empire of the Tsar and would return via
it. In 1901 the Buriat had received initiations into the Time Tantra from
the Ninth Panchen Lama which were supposed to have been of central
significance for his future vision. Ekai Kawaguchi, a Buddhist monk from
Japan who visited Tibet at the turn of the last century, claims to have
heard of a pamphlet in which Dorjiev wrote “Shambhala was Russia. The Emperor, moreover, was an incarnation
of Tsongkhapa, and would sooner or later subdue the whole world and found a
gigantic Buddhist empire” (Snelling, 1993, p. 79). Although it is not
certain whether the lama really did write this document, it fits in with
his religious-political ideas. Additionally, the historians are agreed: “In
my opinion,” W.A. Unkrig writes, “the religiously-based purpose of Agvan
Dorjiev was the foundation of a Lamaist-oriented kingdom of the Tibetans
and Mongols as a theocracy under the Dalai Lama ... [and] under the
protection of Tsarist Russia ... In addition, among the Lamaists there
existed the religiously grounded hope for help from a ‘Messianic Kingdom’
in the North ... called 'Northern Shambhala’” (quoted by Snelling, 1993, p.
79).
At the center of Dorjiev’s activities
in Russia stood the construction of a three-dimensional mandala — the
Buddhist temple in St. Petersburg. The shrine was dedicated to the Kalachakra deity. The Dalai Lama’s
envoy succeeded in bringing together a respectable number of prominent
Russians who approved of and supported the project. The architects came
from the West. A painter by the name of Nicholas Roerich, who later became
a fanatic propagandist for Kalachakra
doctrine, produced the designs for the stained-glass windows. Work commenced
in 1909. In the central hall various main gods from the Tibetan pantheon
were represented with statues and pictures, including among others
Dorjiev’s wrathful initiation deity, Vajrabhairava.
Regarding the décor, it is perhaps also of interest that there was a
swastika motif which the Bolsheviks knocked out during the Second World
War. There was sufficient room for several lamas, who looked after the
ritual life, to live on the grounds. Dorjiev had originally intended to
triple the staffing and to construct not just a temple but also a whole
monastery. This was prevented, however, by the intervention of the Russian
Orthodox Church.
The inauguration took place in 1915, an
important social event with numerous figures from public life and the
official representatives of various Asian countries. The Dalai Lama sent a
powerful delegation, “to represent the Buddhist Papacy and assist the
Tibetan Envoy Dorjiev” (Snelling, 1993, p. 159). Nicholas II had already
viewed the Kalachakra temple
privately together with members of his family several days before the
official occasion.
Officially, the shrine was declared to
be a place for the needs of the Buriat and Kalmyk minorities in the
capital. With regard to its occult functions it was undoubtedly a tantric
mandala with which the Kalachakra
system was to be transplanted into the West. Then, as we have already
explained, from the lamas’ traditional point of view founding a temple is
seen as an act of spiritual occupation of a territory. The legends about
the construction of first Buddhist monastery (Samye) on Tibetan soil show
that it is a matter of a symbolic deed with which the victory of Buddhism
over the native gods (or demons) is celebrated. Such sacred buildings as
the Kalachakra temple in St.
Petersburg are cosmograms which are — in their own way of seeing things —
employed by the lamas as magic seals in order to spiritually subjugate
countries and peoples. It is in this sense that the Italian, Fosco Maraini,
has also described the monasteries in his poetic travelogue about Tibet as
“factories of a holy technology or laboratories of spiritual science”
(Maraini, 1952, p. 172). In our opinion this approximates very closely the
Lamaist self-concept. Perhaps it is also the reason why the Bolsheviks
later housed an evolutionary technology laboratory in the confiscated Kalachakra shrine of St. Petersburg
and performed genetic experiments before the eyes of the tantric terror
gods.
The temple was first returned to the
Buddhists in June 1991. In the same year, a few days before his own death,
the English expert on Buddhism, John Snelling, completed his biography of
the god-king’s Buriat envoy. In it he poses the following possibility: “Who
knows then but what I call Dorjiev's Shambhala
Project for a great Buddhist confederation stretching from Tibet to
Siberia, but now with connections across to Western Europe and even
internationally, may well become a very real possibility” (Snelling, 1993,
xii). Here, Snelling can only mean the explosive spread of Tantric Buddhism
across the whole world.
If we take account of the changes that
time brings with it, then today the Kalachakra
temple in Petersburg would be comparable with the Tibet House in New York. Both institutions function(ed) as
semi-occult centers outwardly disguised as cultural institutions. In both
instances the spread of the Kalachakra
idea is/was central as well. But there is also a much closer connection:
Robert Alexander Farrar Thurman, the founder and current leader of the Tibet House, went to Dharamsala at the
beginning of the sixties. There he was ordained by the Dalai Lama in
person. Subsequently, the Kalmyk, Geshe Wangyal (1901-1983), was appointed
to teach the American, who today proclaims that he shall experience the
Buddhization of the USA in this lifetime. Thurman thus received his tantric
initiations from Wangyal.
This guru lineage establishes a direct
connection to Agvan Dorjiev. Namely, that as a 19-year-old novice Lama
Wangyal accompanied the Buriat to St. Petersburg and was initiated by him.
Thus, Robert Thurman’s “line guru” is, via Wangyal, the old master Dorjiev.
Dorjiev — Wangyal — Thurman form a chain of initiations. From a tantric
viewpoint the spirit of the master live on in the figure of the pupil. It
can thus be assumed that as Dorjiev’s “successor” Thurman represents an
emanation of the extremely aggressive protective deity, Vajrabhairava, who had incarnated
himself in the Buriat. At any rate, Thurman has to be associated with
Dorjiev’s global Shambhala
utopia. His close interconnection with the Kalachakra Tantra is additionally a result of his spending
several months in Dharamsala under the supervision of Namgyal monks, who
are specialized in the time doctrine.
Madame Blavatsky and the Shambhala myth
Yet, as the real pioneering deed in the
spread of the Shambhala myth in
the West we have to present the life and work of a woman. Helena Petrovna
Blavatsky (1831–1891), the influential founder of Theosophy, possibly
contributed more to the globalization of a warlike Buddhism than she was aware
of. The noble-born Russian is supposed to have already been a gifted medium
as a child. After an adventurous life (among other things she worked as a
rider in a circus) her spiritual career as such began in the 1870s in the
USA. At first she tried her hand at all kinds of spiritualist séances. Then
she wrote her first occult book, later world famous, Isis Unveiled (first
published in 1875). As the title reveals, at this stage she oriented
herself to secret Egyptian teachings. There is almost no trace of Buddhist
thought to be found in this work. In 1879 together with her most loyal
follower, Colonel Henry Steele Olcott, Blavatsky made a journey to Bombay
and to the teachings of Buddha Gautama. There too, the doctrine of the
“great White Brotherhood of Tibet” and the mysterious spiritual masters who
determine the fate of humanity was invented, or rather, in Blavatsky’s
terms, “received” from the higher realms.
Tibet, which, her own claims to the contrary,
she had probably never visited, was a grand obsession for the occultist.
She liked to describe her own facial characteristics as
“Kalmyk-Buddhist-Tatar”. Even though her esoteric system is syncretized out
of all religions, since her work on the Secret
Doctrine Tibetan/Tantric Buddhism takes pride of place among them.
A detailed comparison of the later work
of the Theosophist with the Shambhala
myth and the Kalachakra Tantra
would reveal astounding similarities. Admittedly she only knew the Time Tantra
from the brief comments of the first western Tibetologist, the Hungarian,
Csoma de Körös, but her writings are permeated by the same spirit which
also animates the “Highest Tantra of all”. The mystic Secret Book of Dzyan, which the Russian claimed to have
“received” from a Tibetan master and which she wrote her Secret Doctrine as a commentary
upon, is central to her doctrine. It is supposed to be the first volume of
the 21 Books of Kiu te, in which
all the esoteric doctrines of our universe are encoded according to
Blavatsky. What are we dealing with here? The historian David Reigle
suspects that by the mysterious Books
of Kiu te she means the tantra section of the Tibetan Tanjur and Kanjur, the officially codified Tibetan collections of Buddhist
doctrinal writings, about which only little was known at the time. But this
is not certain. There is also supposed to be a Tibetan tradition which
claims that the Books of Kiu te
were all to be found in the kingdom of Shambhala
(Reigle, 1983, p. 3). Following such opinions Madame Blavatsky’s secret
directions would have been drawn directly from the kingdom.
In her philosophy the ADI BUDDHA system
is of central importance, and likewise the fivefold group of the Dhyani (or
meditation) Buddhas and the glorification of Amitabha as the supreme god of light, whom she compares with
the “Ancient of Days” of the
Jewish Cabala. Astutely, she recognizes the Chinese goddess Guanyin as the “genius of water”
(Spierenburg, 1991, p. 13). But as “mother, wife, and daughter” she is
subordinate to the “First Word”, the Tibetan fire god Avalokiteshvara. The result is — as in the Kalachakra Tantra — an obsessive solar and fire cult. Her fire
worship exhibits an original development in the principal deity of our age,
Fohat by name. Among other things
he is said to emanate in all forms of electricity.
Madame Blavatsky was not informed about
the sexual magic practices in the tantras. She herself supported sexual
abstinence as “occult hygiene of mind and body” (Meade, 1987, p. 398). She
claimed to be a virgin all her life, but a report from her doctors reveals
this was not the truth. “To Hades with the sex love!”, she cursed, “It is a
beastly appetite that should be starved into submission” (Symonds, 1959, p.
64). When the sexes first appeared — we learn from the Secret Book of Dzyan — they brought disaster to the world. The
decline into the material began with a sexual indiscretion of the gods:
“They took wives fair to look upon. Wives from the mindless, the
narrow-headed. … Then the third eye acted no longer” (Blavatsky, 1888, vol.
2, p. 13).
Blavatsky was probably convinced that
her female body was being borrowed by a male Tibetan yogi. At any rate her
closest co-worker, Henry Steele Olcott, who so admired her works that he
could not believe they could be the work of a woman, suspected this. Hence, thinking of Madame, he asked an
Indian guru, “But can the atman
[higher self] of a yogi be transferred into the body of a woman?”. The
Indian replied, “He can clothe his soul in her physical form with as much
ease as he can put on a woman's dress. In every physical aspect and
relation he would then be like a woman; internally he would remain himself”
(Symonds, 1959, p. 142). As in the Kalachakra
Tantra, androgyny is also considered the supreme goal along the path to
enlightenment in Theosophy. The gods are simultaneously “male-female”.
Their bisexuality is concentrated in the figure of Avalokiteshvara, the cosmic Adam.
Through her equation of the ADI BUDDHA
with the Bodhisattva Avalokiteshvara Madame
Blavatsky clears the way for a cosmologization of the latter’s earthly
embodiment, the Dalai Lama. For her, the Bodhisattva is “the powerful and
all-seeing”, the “savior of humanity” and we learn that as “the most perfect
Buddha” he will incarnate in the Dalai Lama or the Panchen Lama in order to
redeem the whole world (Blavatsky, 1888, vol. 2, p. 178).
As in the Shambhala myth, the Russian presumes that a secret world
government exists, whose members, the Mahatmas,
were brought together in an esoteric society in the 14th century
by the founder of the Gelugpa order, Tsongkhapa. The “White Brotherhood”,
as this secret federation is known, still exists in Tibet, even if hidden
from view, and influences the fate of humanity. It consists of superhumans
who watch over the evolution of the citizens of the earth.
Likewise, the catastrophic destruction
of the old eon and the creation of a new paradisiacal realm are part of the
Theosophical world view. Here, Blavatsky quotes the same Indian source from
which the Kalachakra Tantra is
also nourished, the Vishnu Purana.
There it says of the doomsday ruler that, “He ... shall descend on Earth as
an outstanding Brahman from Shambhala
... endowed with the eight superhuman faculties. Through his irresistible
power he will ... destroy all whose hearts have been relinquished to evil.
He will re-establish righteousness on earth” (Blavatsky, 1888, vol. 1, p.
378).
Of course, the Russian was able to read
much into the Tibetan Buddhist doctrine, since in her time only a few of
the original texts had been translated into a western language. But it is
definitely wrong to dismiss her numerous theses as pure fantasy, as her
speculative world brings her closer to the imagination and occult ambience
of Lamaism than some philologically accurate translations of Sanskrit
writings. With an unerring instinct and a visionary mastery she discovered
many of the ideas and forces which are at work in the tantric teachings. In
that she attained these insights more through intuition and mediumism than
through scientific research, she can be regarded as the semi-aware
instrument of a Buddhist-Tibetan world conquest. At any rate, of all the
western “believers in Tibet” she contributed the most to the spread of the
idea of the Land of Snows as a unfathomable mystery. Without the occult
veil which Madame Blavatsky cast over Tibet and its clergy, Tantric
Buddhism would only be half as attractive in the West. The Fourteenth Dalai
Lama is also aware of the great importance of such female allies and has
hence frequently praised Blavatsky’s pioneering work.
Nicholas Roerich and the Kalachakra Tantra
A further two individuals who won the
most respect for the Shambhala myth
in the West before the flight of the Fourteenth Dalai Lama, were also
Russians, Nicholas Roerich (1874–1947) and his wife Helena Ivanovna
(1879–1955). Roerich was a lifelong painter, influenced by the late art
nouveau movement. He believed himself to be a reincarnation of Leonardo da
Vinci. Via his paintings, of which the majority featured Asian subjects,
especially the mountainous landscapes of the Himalayas, he attempted to
spread his religious message. He became interested in the ideas of
Theosophy very early on; his wife translated Madame Blavatsky’s Secret Doctrine into Russian. The
occultist led him to Buddhism, which was as we have said en vogue in the society of St.
Petersburg at the time. We have already briefly encountered him as a
designer of Agvan Dorjiev’s Kalachakra
temple. He was a close friend of the Buriat. In contrast, he hated Albert
Grünwedel and regarded his work with deep mistrust.
Between the
years of 1924 and 1928 he wandered throughout Central Asia in search of the
kingdom of Shambhala and subsequently published a travel diary.
In 1929 he began a very successful
international action, the Roerich
Banner of Peace and the Peace
Pact, in which warring nations were supposed to commit themselves to
protecting each other’s cultural assets from destruction. In the White
House in 1935 the Roerich Pact was signed by 21 nations in the presence of
President Franklin Delano Roosevelt. The migrant Russian succeeded in
gaining constant access to circles of government, especially since the
American agricultural minister, Henry Wallace, had adopted him as his guru.
In 1947 the painter died in the Himalayan
foothills of northern India.
With great zeal his wife continued her
husband’s religious work up until the nineteen-fifties. Helena Ivanovna had
from the outset actively participated in the formation of her husband’s
ideas. Above all it is to her that we owe the numerous writings about Agni Yoga, the core of their mutual
teachings. Roerich saw her as something like his shakti, and openly
admitted to her contribution to the development of his vision. He said in
one statement that in his understanding of the world “the duty of the woman
[is] to lead her male partner to the highest and most beautiful, and then
to inspire him to open himself up to the higher world of the spirit and to
import both valuable and beautiful aspects and ethical and social ones into
life” (Augustat, 1993, p. 50). In his otherwise Indian Buddhist doctrinal
system there was a revering of the “mother the world” that probably came
from the Russian Orthodox Church.
Roerich first learned about the Kalachakra Tantra from Agvan Dorjiev
during his work on the temple in St. Petersburg. Later, in Darjeeling, he
had contact to the lama Ngawang Kalzang, who was also the teacher of the
German, Lama Govinda, and was well versed in the time teachings. It is,
however, most unlikely that Roerich received specific initiations from him
or others, as his statements about the Kalachakra
Tantra do not display a great deal of expertise. Perhaps it was
precisely because of this that he saw in it the “happy news “ of the new
eon to come. He thus took up exactly the opposite position to his
contemporary and acquaintance, Albert Grünwedel, who fanatically denounced
the supreme Buddhist doctrinal system as a work of the devil. “Kalachakra”, Roerich wrote, “is the
doctrine which is attributed to the numerous rulers of Shambhala. ... But in reality this doctrine is the great
revelation brought to humankind ... by the lords of fire, the sons of
reason who are and were the lords of Shambhala”
(Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990,
pp. 79, 81).
According to Roerich, the “fiery
doctrine was covered in dust “ up until the twentieth century. (Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p.
122). But now the time had come in which it would spread all over the world.
As far as their essential core was concerned, all other religions were
supposed to be included in the Time Tantra already: “There are now so many
teachers — so different and so hostile to one another; and nonetheless so
many speak of the One, and the Kalachakra
expresses this One”, the Russian has a Tibetan lama say. “One of your
priests once asked me: Are the Cabala and Shambhala not parts of the one teaching? He asked: Is the great
Moses not a initiate of the same doctrine and a servant of its laws?” (Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p.
78).
Agni yoga
For Roerich and
his wife the Time Tantra contains a sparkling fire philosophy: „This
Teaching of Kalachakra, this
utilization of the primary energy, has been called the Teaching of Fire. The
Hindu peoples know the great Agni
— ancient teaching though it be, it shall be the new teaching for the New
Era. We must think of the future; and in the teaching of Kalachakra we know
there lies all the material which
may be applied for greatest use. […] Kalachakra is the Teaching ascribed to
the various Lords of Shambhala […] But in reality this Teaching is the
Great Revelation brought to humanity at the dawn of its conscious evolution
in the third race of the fourth cycle of Earth by the Lords of Fire, the
Sons of reason who were an are the Lords of Shambhala” (Reigle, 1986, p.
38).
The interpretation
which the Russian couple give to the Kalachakra
Tantra in their numerous publications may be described without any
exaggeration as a “pyromaniac obsession”. For them, fire becomes an
autocratic primary substance that dissolves all in its flames. It functions
as the sole creative universal principle. All the other elements, out of
the various admixtures of which the variety of life arises, disappear in the flaming
process of creation: “Do not seek the creative fire in the inertia of
earth, in the seething waves of water, in the storms of the air (H. I.
Roerich, 1980, vol. I, p. 5). Keep away from the other “elements” as “they
do not love fire” (H. I. Roerich, 1980, vol. I, p. 7). Only the “fiery
world” brings blessing. Everyone carries the “sparks of the fiery world in
their hearts” (H. I. Roerich, 1980, vol. II, p. 8). This announces itself
through “fiery signs”. “Rainbow flames” confirm the endeavors of the
spirit. But only after a “baptism of fire” do all the righteous proceed
with “flaming hearts” to the “empire of the fiery world” in which there are
no shadows. They are welcomed by “fire angels”. “The luminosity of every
part of the fiery world generates an everlasting radiance” (H. I. Roerich,
1980, vol. II, p. 8). The “song of fire sounds like the music of the
spheres” (H. I. Roerich, 1980, vol. II, p. 8). At the center of this world
lies the “supreme fire”. Since the small and the large cosmos are one, the
“fiery chakras” of the individual humans correspond to “the fiery
structures of space” (H. I. Roerich, 1980, vol. I, p. 240).
This fire cult is supposed to be
ancient and in the dim and distant past its shrines already stood in the
Himalayas: „Beyond the Kanchenjunga are old menhirs of the great sun cult.
Beyond the Kanchenjunga is the birthplace of the sacred Swastika, sign of
fire. Now in the day of Agni Yoga,
the element of fire is again entering the spirit.” (N. Roerich, 1985, p. 36, 37). Madame Blavatsky’s
above-mentioned god of electricity, Fohat,
is also highly honored by the Roerichs.
The Roerichs’ fiery philosophy is put
into practice through a particular sacred system which is called Agni Yoga. We were unable to
determine the degree to which it follows the traditions of the already
described Sadanga Yoga, practiced
in the Kalachakra Tantra. Agni Yoga gives the impression that
is conducted more ethically and with feelings than technically and with
method. Admittedly the Roerich texts also talk of an unchaining of the kundalini (fire serpent), but
nowhere is there discussion of sexual practices. In contrast -the
philosophy of the two Russians requires strict abstinence and is
antagonistic to everything erotic.
In 1920 the
first Agni Yoga group was founded
by the married couple. The teachings, we learn, come from the East , indeed
direct from the mythical kingdom: „And Asia when she speaks the Blessed Shambhala, about Agni Yoga, about the Teaching of
Flame, knows that the holy spirit of flame can unite the human hearts in a
resplendent evolution” (N. Roerich, 1985, p. 294). Agni
Yoga is supposed to
join the great world religions together and serve as a common basis for
them.
With great regret the Roerichs discover
that the people do not listen to the “fiery tongues” that speak to them and
want to initiate them into the secrets of the flames. They appropriated
only the external appearances of the force of fire, like electricity, and
otherwise feared the element. Yet the “space fire demands revelation” and
whoever closes out its voice will perish in the flames (H. I. Roerich,
1980, p. 30).
Even if it is predicted in the cosmic
plan, the destruction of all dark and ignorant powers does not happen by
itself. It needs to be accelerated by the forces of good. It is a matter of
victory and defeat, of heroic courage and sacrificial death. Here is the
moment in which the figure of the Shambhala
warriors steps into the plan and battles with the inexorably advancing Evil
which wants to extinguish Holy Flame: “They shall come — the extinguishers;
they shall come — the destroyers; they shall come — the powers of darkness.
Corrosion that has already begun cannot be checked” (H. I. Roerich, 1980,
vol. I, p. 124).
Shambhala
We hear from Helena Ivanova Roerich that
“the term Shambhala truly is
inseparably linked to fiery apparitions” (H. I. Roerich, 1980, vol. I, p.
26). “Fire signs introduce the epoch of Shambhala”,
writes her spouse (Schule der
Lebensweisheit, 1990, p. 29). It is not surprising that the Russian visionaries
imagined the temple of Shambhala
as an “alchemic laboratory”, then a fire oven, the athanor, also stood at the heart of the hermetic art, as
western alchemy was known.
The couple consider Shambhala, the “city of happiness”,
to be the “geographic residence or workplace of the brotherhood and seat of
the interplanetary government in the trans-Himalaya” (Augustat, 1993, p.
153). In an official fundamental declaration of the two it says: “The
brotherhood is the spiritual union of highly developed entities from other
planets or hierarchs, which as a cosmic institution is responsible to a
higher institution for the entire evolution of the planet Earth. The
interplanetary government consists of cosmic offices, which are occupied by
the hierarch depending on the task and the age” (Augustat, 1993, p. 149).
The Mahatmas, as these hierarchs
are called in reference to Madame Blavatsky, have practical political power
interests and are in direct contact with certain heads of state of our
world, even if the ordinary mortals have no inkling of this.
Then it is impossible for normal humans
to discover the main lodge of the secret society: “How can one find the way
to our laboratories? Without being called no-one will get to us”, Roerich
proclaims (Schule der Lebensweisheit,
1990, p. 9). From there the Mahatmas
coordinate an army of in part paid agents, who operate here on Earth in the
name of the hidden kingdom. In the meantime the whole planet is covered by
a net of members, assistants, contacts, and spies of the “international
government” who are only waiting for the sign from their command center in Shambhala in order to step into the
light and reveal themselves to humanity.
Likewise, the activities and
resolutions of the “invisible international government” are all but
impenetrable for an outsider. There is a law which states that each earthly
nation will only be visited and “warned” by an envoy from Shambhala once in a century. An
exception was probably made during the French Revolution, then “hierarchs”
like the Comte de Saint Germain for example were extremely active at this
troubled time. Sadly he died in the year 1784 “as a result of the
undisciplined thinking of one of his assistants”. (Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p. 117). The dissolute life of
his sadhaka (pupil), Cagliostro, was probably to blame for his not being
able to participate in the great events of 1789 (the storming of the
Bastille).
According to Roerich the members of the
government of Shambhala have the
ability to telepathically penetrate into the consciousness of the citizens
of Earth without them realizing where particular ideas come from: “Like
arrows the transmissions of the community bore into the brains of humanity”
(Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990,
p. 10). Sometimes this takes place using apparatuses especially constructed
for this purpose. But they are not permitted to openly reveal their amazing
magical abilities: “Who can exist without food? Who can get by without
sleep? Who is immune to heat and cold? Who can heal wounds? Truly only one
who has studied Kalachakra” (Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p.
77).
Tableau of N. Roerich: “The command of
Rigden-jyepo”
For the Russian couple all the
interventions of the governing yogi caste have just one goal, to prepare for
the coming of the future Buddha Maitreya
Morya or Rigden-jyepo, who
shall then make all important decisions. According to the Roerichs both
names are synonyms for the Rudra
Chakrin, the “wrathful wheel turner” and doomsday ruler of the Kalachakra Tantra. We thus await a
fairytale oriental despot who cares about his subjects: “Just like a
diamond the light shines from the tower of Shambhala. He is there — Rigden-jyepo,
untiring, ever watchful for the sake of humanity. His eyes never close. In
his magic mirror he sees everything which happens on Earth. And the power
of his thoughts penetrates through to the distant countries. ... His
immeasurable riches lay waiting to help all the needy who offer to serve
the cause of uprightness” (Augustat, 1993, p. 11).
In passing, this doomsday emperor from Shambhala also reveals himself to be
the western king of the Holy Grail, who holds the Holy Stone in his hands
and who emigrated to Tibet under cover centuries ago. He is returning now,
messengers announce him. True Knights of the Holy Grail are already
incarnated on Earth, unrecognized . The followers of the Roerichs even
believe that their master himself protected the grail for a time and then
returned it to Shambhala on his
trip to Asia (Augustat, 1993, p. 114).
Apocalypse now
"Why do clouds gather when the
Stone [the Grail] becomes dull? If the Stone becomes heavy, blood shall be
spilled”, we learn mysteriously (Schule
der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p. 88). Behind this secret of the grail lies
the apodictic statement known from almost all religions that total war,
indeed the destruction of the world, is necessary in order to attain
paradise. It is essential because in a good dualist cliché the “brotherhood
of Good” is always counterposed by the “brotherhood of Evil”. The “sons of
darkness” have succeeded in severing humanity’s connection to the “higher
world”, the “bright hierarchy”. The forces of the depths lurk everywhere.
Extreme caution is required since an ordinary mortal can barely distinguish
the Evil from the Good, and further, “the brotherhood of Evil attempts to
imitate the Good’s method of action” (Schule
der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p. 126).
The final battle between Light and
Darkness is — the Roerichs say- presaged in the prophecies of the ancestors
and the writings of the wise and must therefore take place. When natural
disasters and crimes begin to pile up on Earth, the warriors from Shambhala will appear. At the head
of their army stands the Buddha Maitreya
Morya, who “ [combats] the prince of darkness himself. This struggle
primarily takes place in the subtle spheres, whereas here [on earth] the
ruler of Shambhala operates
through his earthly warriors. He himself can only be seen under the most
exceptional circumstances and would never appear in a crowd or among the
curious. His appearance in fiery form would be disastrous for everybody and
everything since his aura is loaded with energies of immense strength” (Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p.
152). It could be thought that this concerned an atomic bomb. At any rate
the battle will be conducted with a fire and explosive power which allows
of comparison only to the atomic detonations in Hiroshima and Nagasaki:
Fiery the battle
with blazing torches,
Blood red the arrows
against the shining shield
(Schule der Lebensweisheit, 1990, p. 110)
Thus the armies
of Shambhala storm forth. „Space
is filled with fire. The lightning of the Kalki avatar [Rudra
Chakrin] — the preordained Maitreya
— flashes upon the” (N. Roerich, 1985, p. 76). Even if Kalki
also goes by the epithet of “Lord of Compassion”, with his enemies he knows
no mercy. Accompanied by Gesar,
the mythic war hero of the Tibetans, he will storm forward mounted on a
“white horse” and with a “comet-like, fiery sword” in his hand. Iron snakes
will consume outer space with fire and frenzy (N. Roerich, 1988 p. 12).
“The Lord”, we read, “ strikes the people with fire. The same fiery element
presides over the Day of Judgment. The purification of evil is performed by
fire. Misfortunes are accompanied by fires” (H. I. Roerich, 1980, vol. I,
46).
Those who fight for Shambhala are the precursors of a
new race who take control of the universe after Armageddon, after the
“wheat has been separated from the chaff” (Augustat,1993, p. 98). That is,
to put it plainly, after all the inferior races have been eradicated in a
holocaust.
Distribution in the west
As far as the fate of Tibet is
concerned, the prophecies that Roerich made at the end of the twenties have
in fact been fulfilled: „We must accept it simply, as it is: the fact that
the true teaching shall leave Tibet”, he has a lama announce, „and shall
again appear in the South. In all countries, the covenants of Buddha shall
be manifested. Really, great things are coming.” (N. Roerich, 1985, p. 3) In 1959 the Fourteenth
Dalai Lama fled to India in the south and from this point in time onwards
Tibetan Buddhism began to be spread all around the world.
Roerich and his wife saw themselves as
agents of Shambhala who were
supposed to make contact with those governing our world in order to warn
them. They could at any rate appeal to a meeting with Franklin Delano
Roosevelt. Their followers, however, believe that they were higher up in
the hierarchy and that they were incarnated Mahatmas from the kingdom.
In the meantime the Roerich cult is
most popular in Eastern Europe, where even before the fall of Communism it
had penetrated the highest circles of government. The former Bulgarian
Minister for Culture, Ludmilla Shiffkova, daughter of the Communist head of
state Todor Shiffkov, was almost fanatically obsessed with the Agni master’s philosophy, so that
she planned to introduce his teachings as part of the official school
curriculum. For a whole year, cultural policy was conducted under the motto
“N. K. Roerich — A cultural world citizen”, and she also organized several
overseas exhibitions including works by her spiritual model as well.
Mikhail Gorbachev and his wife also
supported numerous Roerich initiatives. In Russia, the renaissance of the
visionary painter was heralded for years in advance in elaborate symposia
and exhibitions, in order to then fully blossom in the post-Communist era.
In Alma Ata in October 1992, a major ecumenical event was organized by the
international Roerich groups under the patronage of the president of
Kazakhstan, at the geographical gateway, so to speak, behind which the land
of Shambhala is widely believed
to have once lain. The Fourteenth Dalai Lama hesitated as to whether he
ought to visit the Congress before deciding for scheduling reasons to send
a telegram of greeting and a high-ranking representative.
The “Shambhala warrior” Chögyam Trungpa
In 1975 the Tibetan, Chögyam Trungpa
(1940–1987), gathered several of his western pupils around himself and
began to initiate them into a special spiritual discipline which he
referred to as “Shambhala Training”.
As a thirteen-month-old infant the Rinpoche from the Tibetan province of
Kham was recognized as the tenth reincarnation of the Trungpa and accepted
into the Kagyupa order. In 1959 he had to flee from the Chinese. In 1963 he
traveled to England and studied western philosophy and comparative religion
at Oxford. Like no other Tibetan lama of his time, he understood how to
make his own contribution to western civilization and culture. As a
brilliant rhetorician, poet, and exotic free spirit he soon found numerous
enthusiastic listeners and followers. In 1967 he founded the first European
tantric monastery in Scotland. He gave it the name and the ground-plan of Samye Ling — in remembrance of the
inaugural Tibetan shrine of the same name that Padmasambhava erected at the
end of the 8th century despite resistance from countless demons.
In the opinion of Trungpa’s followers
the demonic resistance was enormous in Scotland too: In 1969 the young lama
was the victim of a serious car accident which left him with a permanent
limp. There is an ambiguous anecdote about this unfortunate event. Trungpa
had reached a fork in the road in his car — to the right the road led in
the direction of his monastery, the road to the left to the house in which
his future wife lived. But he continued to drive straight ahead, plowing
right into a shop selling magic and joke articles. Nevertheless, his
meteoric rise had begun. In 1970 he went to the United States.
Trungpa’s charming and initially
anarchic manner, his humor and loyalty, his lack of respect and his laugh
magnetically attracted many young people from the sixties generation. They
believed that here the sweet but dangerous mixture of the exotic, social
critique, free love, mind-expanding drugs, spirituality, political activism
and self-discovery, which they had tasted in the revolutionary years of
their youth, could be rediscovered. Trungpa’s friendship with the radical
beatnik poet Allan Ginsberg and other well-known American poets further
enhanced his image as a “wild boy” from the roof of world. Even the first
monastery he founded, Samye Ling,
was renowned for the permissive “spiritual” parties which were held there
and for the liberal sex and drug consumption.
But such excesses are only one side of
things. Via the tantric law of inversion Trungpa intended to ultimately
transform all this abandon (his own and that of his pupils) into
discipline, goodness, and enlightened consciousness. The success of the
guru was boundless. Many thousands cam to him as pilgrims. All over America
and Europe spiritual centers (dharmadhatus)
were created. The Naropa Institute
(near Denver, Colorado) was established as a private university, where alongside
various Buddhist disciplines fine arts could also be studied.
The Shambhala warrior
Trungpa had told one of his pupils that
during deep meditation he was able to espy Shambhala. He also said he had obtained the teachings for the “Shambhala training” directly from the kingdom. The program consists of
five levels: 1. The art of being human; 2. Birth of the warrior; 3. Warrior
in the world; 4. Awakened heart; 5. Open sky: The big bang. Anyone who had
completed all the stages was considered a perfect “Shambhala warrior”. As a spiritual hero he is freed from the
repulsiveness which the military trade otherwise implies. His
characteristics are kindness, an open heart, dignity, elegance, precision,
modesty, attentiveness, fearlessness, equanimity, concentration, and
confidence of victory. To be a warrior, one of
Trungpa’s pupils writes, irrespective of whether as a man or a woman, means
to live honestly, also in regard to fear, doubt, depression, and aggression
which comes from outside. To be a warrior does not mean to conduct wars.
Rather, to be a warrior means to have the courage to completely fathom
oneself (Hayward, 1997, p. 11). This subjectification of the warrior ethos brings with it that the
weapons employed first of all represent purely psycho-physical states:
controlled breathing, the strict stance, walking upright, clear sight.
The first basic
demand of the training is, as in every tantric practice, a state of
„egolessness”. This is of great importance in the Shambhala teachings, writes Trungpa. It is impossible to be a
warrior if you have not experienced egolessness. Without egolessness, your
consciousness is always filled with your ego, your personal plans and
intentions (Hayward, 1997, p. 247). Hence the individual ego is not changed through the
exercises, rather the pupil tries solely to create an inner emptiness.
Through this he allows himself to be transformed into a vessel into which
the cult figures of the Tibetan pantheon can flow. According to Trungpa
these are called dralas.
Translated literally, that means “to climb out over the enemy” or in an
further sense, energy, line of force, or “gods”.
The “empty” pupils thus become occupied
by tantric deities. As potential “warriors” they naturally attract all
possible forms of eager to fight dharmapalas
(tutelary gods). Thus a wrathful Tibetan “protector of the faith” steps in
to replace the sadhaka and his
previous western identity. This personal transformation takes place through
a ritual which in Trungpa’s Shambhala
tradition is known as “calling the gods”. The supernatural beings are
summoned with spells and burning incense. When
the thick, sweet-smelling white smoke ascends, the pupils sing a long
incantation, which summons the dralas.
At the end of the song the warrior pupils circle the smoke in a clockwise
direction and constantly emit the victory call of the warrior (Hayward,
1997, p. 275).
This latter
is “Lha Gyelo — victory to the
gods” — the same call which the Dalai Lama cried out as he crossed the
Tibetan border on his flight in 1959.
Trungpa was even more fascinated by the
ancient national hero, Gesar,
whose barbaric daredevilry we have already sketched in detail, than he was
by the dharmapalas. The guru
recommended the atavistic war hero to his followers as an example to
imitate. Time and again he proudly indicated that his family belonged to
the belligerent nomadic tribe of the “Mukpo”, from whose ranks Gesar also came. For this reason he
ennobled his pupils as the “Mukpo family” and thus proclaimed them to be
comrades-in-arms of Gesar. The
latter — said Trungpa — would return from Shambhala, “leading an army to conquer the forces of darkness
in the world” (Trungpa, 1986, p. 7).
But Trungpa did not just summon up
Tibetan dharmapalas and heroes
with his magic, rather he also invoked the deceased spirits of an
international, on closer examination extremely problematic, warrior caste:
the Japanese samurai, the North American plains Indians, the Jewish King
David, and the British King Arthur with his round table — all archetypal
leading figures who believed that justice could only be achieved with a
sword in the hand, who were all absolutely ruthless in creating peace.
These “holy warriors” always stood opposed to the “barbarians” of another
religion who had to be exterminated. The non-dualist world view which many
of the original Buddhist texts so forcefully demand is completely cancelled
out in the mythic histories of these warlike models.
Trungpa led his courses under the name
of “Dorje Dradul” which means
“invincible warrior”. Completely in accord with an atavistic fighter
tradition only beasts of prey were accepted as totem animals for his
pupils: the snow lion, the tiger, the dragon. Dorje Dradul was especially enthusiastic about the mythic sun
bird, the garuda, about its fiery
redness, wildness, and its piercing cry commanding the cessation of thought
like a lightning bolt (Hayward, 197, p. 251). Garuda is the sun bird par excellence, and since time immemorial the followers of the
warrior caste have also been worshippers of
the sun. Thus in the center of Trungpa’s Shambhala mission a solar cult is fostered. But it is not the
natural sun which lights up all, but rather the “Great Eastern Sun” which
rises at the beginning of a new world era when the Shambhala warriors seize power over the world. It sinks as a
mighty cult symbol into the hearts of his pupils: “So, we begin to
appreciate the Great Eastern Sun,
not as something outside from us, like the sun in the sky, but as the Great
Eastern Sun in our head and shoulders, in our face, our hair, our lips, our
chest” (Trungpa, 1986, p. 39). Why of all people it was the chairman of the
Communist Party of China, Mao Zedong, who was worshipped by the Red Guard
as the Great Eastern Sun is a
topic to which we shall return.
The
basic ideology of the Shambhala program divides the world into two visions:
Great Eastern Sun, which corresponds to enlightenment in the Buddhist path,
and setting sun, which corresponds to samsara. [...] Great Eastern Sun is
cheering up; setting sun is complaining and criticizing. Great Eastern sun
ist elegant und rich; setting sun is sloppy and poor. To paraphrase George
Orwell: “Great Eastern Sun good, setting sun bad.” (Butterfield, 1994, p.
96).
From anarchy to despotism
Trungpa played brilliantly with the interchangeability
of reality and non-reality, even regarding his own person, he was
especially a master of the tantric law of inversion. He thus simply
declared his excessive alcoholism and his sexual cravings to be the
practicing of the tantra path. Whether alcohol is a poison or a medicine
depends on one’s own attentiveness. Conscious drinking — that is when the
drinker remains self-aware — changes the effect of the alcohol. Here the
system is steeled through attentiveness. Alcohol becomes an intelligent
protective mechanism. But it has a destructive effect if one abandons
oneself to comfort (Hayward, 1997, pp. 306–307). Yet Dorje
Dradul was not free of the aggressive moods which normally occur in
heavy alcoholics. He thus spread fear and horror through his frequent angry
outbursts. But his pupils forgave him everything, proclaimed him a “holy
fool” and praised his excesses as the expression of a “crazy wisdom”. They often attempted
to emulate his alcoholism: I think there is a message for us in his drinking,
Dennis Ann Roberts believed, “I know his drinking has certainly encouraged
all of us to drink more” (Boucher, 1985, p. 243). Another pupil
enthusiastically wrote: “He's great. I love the fact that he works on his
problems the way he does. He doesn't hide it. He drinks, and it's almost
killed him. So he is working on it. I find that great” (Boucher, 1985, p.
243).
Similar reasons are offered for his
sexual escapades. In 1970 he abandoned his vow of celibacy and married a young
British aristocrat. His bride is said to have been thirteen years old in
1969 (Tibetan Review, August
1987, p. 21). In addition he had a considerable number of yoginis, who were
obviously uninformed about the andocentric manipulations of Tantrism. There
was admittedly a minor rebellion among the female followers when the
Karmapa insisted on talking only with the men during his visit to a Trungpa
center, but essentially the western karma
mudras occupied by Tibetan deities behaved loyally towards their lord
and master. A lot of women have been consorts of Rinpoche — one of them
tells that “The Tibetans are into passion, they think sexuality is an
essential energy to work with. You don't reject it. So it's a whole other
perception of sexuality anyway” (Boucher, 1985, p. 244).
Such affirmations of tantric practice
by the female pupils are definitely not exceptions and they most clearly
testify to the charisma which the tantra master projects. Thus we learn
from another of Trungpa’s lovers, “My first meeting with him was a real
turn-off. I mean, I didn't want a guru who did things like that. The irony
was that I had left my other Tibetan Buddhist teacher partly because he was
coming on to me. And I just couldn't handle it. And Rinpoche is very much
into alcohol and having girl friends. Now it makes total sense to me”
(Boucher, 1985, p. 241).
Chögyam Trungpa has obviously succeeded
in keeping his western karma mudras
under control. This was much more difficult for the Tibetan Tantric, Gedun
Chöpel, who died in 1951. He left behind an amusing estimation of the
“women of the west” from the thirties which shows how much has changed in
the meantime: “In general a girl of the west is beautiful, splendorous, and
more courageous than others. Her behavior is coarse, and her face is like a
man's. There is even hair around her mouth. Fearless and terrifying, she
can be tamed only by passion. Able to suck the phallus at the time of play,
the girl of the west is known to drink regenerative fluid. She does it even
with dogs, bulls and any other animals and with father and son, etc. She
goes without hesitation with whoever can give the enjoyment of sex”
(Chöpel, 1992, p. 163).
Towards the end of his life, Trungpa
the “indestructible warrior” moved further and further away from his Hippie
past. As the head of his lineage the Karmapa is said to have not been at
all pleased to observe the permissive practices in the “wild” guru’s
centers. However, in accordance with the tantric “law of inversion”, after
a few years the pendulum swung from anarchy to the other pole of despotism
and all at once Trungpa abandoned himself to his fascistoid dreams. His
protective troops, Dorje Kasung,
initially a kind of bodyguard composed of volunteers was transformed within
a short period into a paramilitary unit in khaki uniforms. The guru himself
put aside his civilian clothing for a time and appeared in high-ranking
military dress as a “Shambhala
general”. We do not know whether, alongside the warlike ethos of the
tantric tradition, the physical handicap which he sustained in his car
accident in England did not also trigger his unusual interest in military
things as a counter-reaction. At any rate his “military parades” became a
fixed part of the Shambhala
training.
On other occasions the former “freak”
donned a pinstripe suit with a colorful tie and looked like nothing more
than an Asian film gangster. Thus he really did play brilliantly through
the ambivalent spectrum completely laid out in the tantric repertoire, from
poetic anarchist and flower power dancer to saber-rattling dictator and
underworld boss. In 1987 the master warrior died and his body was committed
to the flames in Vermont (USA).
“’May
I shrivel up instantly and rot,’ we vowed, ‘if I ever discuss these
theachings with anyone who has not been initiated into them by a qualified
master.’ As if this were not enough, Trungpa told us that if we ever tried
to leave Vajrayana, we would suffer unbearable, subtle, continuous anguish,
and disasters would pursue us like furies. Heresy had real meaning in this
religion, and real consequences. Doubting the dharma or the guru and
associating with heretics were causes for downfall. In Tibetan literature,
breaking faith with the guru must be atoned by such drastic measures as
cutting off your arms and offering it at the door of his cave in hopes that
he might take you back.” – “To be part of Trungpa’s inner circle, you had
to take a vow never to reveal or even discuss some of the things he did.
This personal secrecy is common with gurus, especially in Vajrayana
Buddhism. It is also common in the dysfunctional family system of
alcoholics and sexual abusers. This inner circle secrecy puts up an almost
insurmountable barrier of a healthily skeptical mind.” (Butterfield, 1994,
p. 11, 100) Trungpa’s Shambhala
Warriors see:
http://sealevel.ns.ca/ctr/photo01.html and
http://www.shambhalashop.com/archives/junephoto/june12.html
The inheritance
The immediate inheritance which Trungpa
left behind him was catastrophic. Completely in the spirit of his Tibetan
guru, the American, Thomas Rich, who succeeded him under the name of “Vajra
Regent Ösel Tendzin”, continued the carefree permissiveness of his master
with a tantric justification. However, in 1988 there was a scandal from
which the organization has not fully recovered to this day. The “Vajra
Regent” had been HIV positive for three years and had infected numerous
members with the AIDS virus in the meantime. He died in 1991. Trungpa’s
son, Sawang Ösel Rangdroel, then took over the leadership.
“From
Vajrayana point of view, passion, aggression, and ignorance, the sources of
human suffering, are also the well-spring of enlightenment. Afflictions like
AIDS are not merely disasters, but accelrations toward wisdom, and
opportunities to wake up. They can be transformed into buddha-mind. Trungpa
was a Vajra master who had empowered Tendzin to guide students on this
path” (Butterfield, 1994, p. 7).
Even if Trungpa’s Shambhala warriors have
forfeited quite a deal of their attractiveness in recent years, thousands
still revere the master as the “holy fool” and “indestructible warrior”,
who brought the “Eastern sun” to the West. For this reason he is said to
also be prayed to in the whole of Asia as a great Bodhisattva and Maha Siddha (Hayward, 1997, p. 319).
“For ten years he presented the Shambhala
Teachings”, summarizes one of his sadhakas, “In terms of time and
history, that seems insignificant; however in that short span he set in
motion the powerful force of goodness that can actually change the world”
(Trungpa, 1986, p. 157). Only rarely does a “deserter” go public, like P.
Marin for example, a strong critic of the Naropa Institute, for whom this
western Tibetan Buddhist organization is “a feudal, priestly tradition
transplanted to a capitalist setting” (quoted by Bishop, 1993, p. 101).
On the other hand it goes without
saying that the Tantric Trungpa time and again draws attention to the fact
that the warlike figures he invokes are illusionary reflections of the
human ego and that even the Shambhala
kings are projections of one’s own consciousness. But if everything really
can be reduced to forms of consciousness, then it remains totally unclear
why it is time and again the phantoms of a destructive black-and-white mode
of thought which are summoned up to serve as examples along the personal
initiation path. Wouldn’t it make more sense, indeed be more logical, to
directly conjure up those “peace gods” who have surmounted such dualist
thought patterns? What is the reason for this glorification of an atavistic
warrior caste?
It goes without saying that in
Trungpa’s system no-one is entitled to even dream of critically examining
the dralas (gods). Although only
projections of one’s own consciousness according to the doctrine, they are
considered sacrosanct. They are pure, good, and exemplary. Since Trungpa’s Shambhala Training unquestioningly
incorporates all of the established tantric deities, the entire martial
field of Tibetan Buddhism with its entrenched concept of “the enemy” and
its repellant daemonic power is adopted by people who naively and
obligingly set out to attain personal enlightenment.
We thus have the impression that the pupils
of the tantra masters are exposed to a hypnotic suggestion so as to make
them believe that their own spiritual development was the agenda whereas
they have long since become the pawns of Tibetan occultism in whose
unfathomable net of regulations (tantra
means ‘net’) they have become entrapped. Once their personal ambitions
have been dissolved into nothingness they can be enslaved as the loyal
lackeys of a spiritual power politics which no longer sees the “higher
self” in the “universal monarch” but rather a real political “wrathful
wheel turner” (Rudra Chakrin) who
lays waste to the world with his armies from Shambhala so as to then establish a global Buddhocracy.
Other Western Shambhala visions
James Hilton's novella, Lost Horizon, published in 1933,
counts among the best-sellers of the last century. It tells of a monastery in the Land of Snows whose name, Shangri-La, is reminiscent of the
kingdom of Shambhala. The term
has in the meantime become a synonym for leisure, refinement, and taste, at
least in the English-speaking world, and is employed by an Asian luxury
hotel chain. The idyll described in the book concerns people who had
retreated from the hustle and bustle of the modern world to the Himalayas
and now devote themselves to exclusively spiritual enjoyments. It is,
however, no Tibetan tulku but rather a Catholic missionary who collects
together those tired of civilization in a hidden valley in the Land of
Snows so as to share with them a study of the fine arts and an extended
lifespan. The “monks” from the West do not even need to do without European
bathtubs — otherwise unknown in the Tibet of the thirties. The essence of
the Shangri- La myth ultimately
consists in the transportation of “real” products of European culture and
civilization to the “roof of the world”.
The most recent western attempt at
spreading the Tibetan myth is Victoria LePage's book, Shambhala. The author presents the secret kingdom as an
overarching mystery school, whose high priests are active as “an invisible,
scientific and philosophical society which pursues its studies in the
majestic isolation of the Himalayas” (LePage, 1996, p. 13). For LePage Shambhala is the esoteric center of
all religions, the secret location from which every significant occult, and
hence also religious, current of the world has emanated. Esoteric Buddhism,
and likewise the ancient Egyptian priestly schools, the Pythagoreans,
Sufism, the Knights Templar, alchemy, the Cabala, Freemasonry, Theosophy —
yes even the witches cults — all originated here. Accordingly, the Kalachakra Tantra is the overarching
“secret doctrine” from which all other mystery doctrines may be derived
(LePage, 1996, p. 8).
The mythic kingdom, which is governed
by a sun ruler, is to be found in Central Asia, there where the axis of the
world, Mount Meru, is also to be sought. This carefree adoption of Buddhist
cosmology does not present the author with any difficulties since the axis mundi is said to only be
visible to the initiated. In accordance with the mandala principle her Shambhala has distributed numerous
copies of itself all over the world — the Pyramids of Giza, the monastery
at Athos, Kailash, the holy mountain. Sites of the Grail like Glastonbury
and Rennes le Chateau are such “offshoots” of the hidden imperium — likewise
only perceivable through initiated eyes. Together they form the acupuncture
points of a cosmic body which corresponds to the mystic body of the Kalachakra master (i.e., taken
literally, in the energy body of the Dalai Lama). LePage too, sees a great
“mystic clock” in the Time Tantra. The segments of this time machine record
the cyclical periods of the course of the world. A “hidden directorate”, a
mysterious brotherhood of immortal beings in the Himalayas, ensures that
the cosmic hours marked on the clockface are adhered to.
The Fourteenth Dalai Lama and the Shambhala myth
LePage's global monopolization of the
entire cultic life of our planet by the Kalachakra
Tantra could be regarded as an important step in a worldwide
Shambhalization plan of the Fourteenth Dalai Lama. Nonetheless, the Kundun deliberately prefers to leave
such esoteric speculations (which are in no way at odds with his doctrine)
to others, best of all “hobby Buddhists” like the author. So as not to lose
political respectability, the Kundun
keeps his statements about the Shambhala
question enigmatic: “Even for me Shambhala
remains a puzzling, even paradox country”, the highest Kalachakra master reassures his listeners (Levenson, 1992, p.
305). All that we hear from him concretely is the statement that “the
kingdom of Shambhala does indeed
exist, but not in the usual sense” (Dalai Lama Fourteenth, 1993a, p. 307).
Can we expect a total world war in
circa 300 years in accordance with the prophecy? His Holiness has no doubts
about this either: “That lies in the logic of circulation!” (Levenson,
1992, p. 305). But then he modifies his statement again and speculates
about whether the final battle is not to be interpreted as a psychological
process within the individual. For dreamers for whom such a psychological
interpretation is too dry, however, the Kundun
subsequently hints that Shambhala
could perhaps concern another planet and the soldiers of the kingdom could
be extraterrestrials (Levenson, 1992, p. 305).
He understands how to rapidly switch
between various levels of reality like a juggler and thus further enhance
the occult ambience which already surrounds the Shambhala myth anyway. „Secrets partly revealed
are powerful”, writes Christiaan Klieger, and continues, „The ability of
the Dalai Lama to skillfully manipulate a complex of meaning and to present appropriate
segments of this to his people and the world is part of his success as a
leader” (Klieger, 1991, p. 76). Ultimately, everything is possible in this deliberate confusion, for
example that the Shambhala king
in person stands before us in the figure of His Holiness as some
worshippers believe, or that Lhasa is the capital of the mythic country of
“Kalapa” albeit not visible to mortal eyes. Should the Kundun some day return to Tibet as a savior — some people
believe — then the veil would be lifted and the earthly/supernatural
kingdom (Shambhala) would reveal
itself to the world.
Similar speculations are in fact very
popular in the Buddhist scene. On the official (!) homepage of the Kalachakra Tantra the “dharma
master”, Khamtrul Rinpoche, explains to his readers that the current Dalai
Lama is an incarnation of Kulika Pundarika, the eighth Shambhala king famed as the first commentator on the Time
Tantra. But it gets better: “My companion [the goddess Tara, who led him through Shambhala
in a dream]", Khamtrul writes, “told me that the last Kulika King will
be called Rudra with a wheel,
'the powerful and ferocious king who holds an iron wheel in his hand' ...
and he will be none other than His Holiness the Dalai Lama, who will subdue
everything evil in the universe” (Khamtrul, HPI 005). Following this
revelation, which prophecies the Kundun
as the military commander of an apocalyptic army, Rinpoche worries whether
the Shambhala army is a match for
the modern armaments industry with its missiles and nuclear bombs. Here the
kindly Tara comforts and
reassures him that no matter what weapons of mass destruction may be
produced in our world, a superior counter-weapon would automatically be
created by Shambhala’s magic
armaments industry (Khamtrul, HPI 005).
In the words of the Fourteenth Dalai
Lama “world peace” is supposed to be strengthened with every Kalachakra ritual. He repeats this
again and again! But is this really his intention?
With an ironic undertone, the
Tibetologist Donald L. Lopez (formerly one of the closest followers of the Kundun), writes in the final section
of his book, Prisoners of Shangri-La,
that “this peace may have a special meaning, however, for those who
take the initiation are planting the seeds to be reborn in their next
lifetime in Shambhala, the Buddhist pure land across the mountains
dedicated to the preservation of Buddhism. In the year 2245 [?], the army
of the king will sweep out of Shambhala and defeat the barbarians in a
Buddhist Armageddon,[!] restoring Buddhism to India and to the world and
ushering in a reign of peace” (Lopez, 1998, p. 207).
Back to Contents
Next Chapter:
12. FASCISM
AND IT’S CLOSE RELATIONSHIP TO BUDDHIST TANTRISM
|