by Shannon Hall
May 15, 2018

from QuantaMagazine website





Olena Shmahalo

Quanta Magazine



Astronomers argue that

there's an undiscovered giant planet

far beyond the orbit of Neptune.

A newly discovered rocky body

has added evidence to

the circumstantial case for it.

In early 2016, two planetary scientists declared that a ghost planet is hiding in the depths of the solar system, well beyond the orbit of Pluto.

Their claim, which they made based on the curious orbits of distant icy worlds, quickly sparked a race to find this so-called Planet Nine (Ex-Planet X or 10) - a planet that is estimated to be about 10 times the mass of Earth.

"It has a real magnetism to it," said Gregory Laughlin, an astronomer at Yale University.

 

"I mean, finding a 10-Earth-mass planet in our own solar system would be a discovery of unrivaled scientific magnitude."

Now, astronomers are reporting that they have spotted another distant world (Discovery and Dynamical Analysis of an Extreme Trans-Neptunian Object with a High Orbital Inclination) - perhaps as large as a dwarf planet - whose orbit is so odd that it is likely to have been shepherded by Planet Nine.

The object confirms a specific prediction made by Konstantin Batygin and Michael Brown, the astronomers at the California Institute of Technology who first argued for Planet Nine's existence.

"It's not proof that Planet Nine exists," said David Gerdes, an astronomer at the University of Michigan and a co-author on the new paper.

 

"But I would say the presence of an object like this in our solar system bolsters the case for Planet Nine."

Lucy Reading-Ikkanda

Quanta Magazine

David Gerdes and his colleagues spotted the new object in data from the Dark Energy Survey, a project that probes the acceleration in the expansion of the universe by surveying a region well above the plane of the solar system.

This makes it an unlikely tool for finding objects inside the solar system, since they mostly orbit within the plane.

But that is exactly what makes the new object unique:

its orbit is tilted 54 degrees with respect to the plane of the solar system.

It's something Gerdes did not expect to see. Batygin and Brown, however, predicted it.

Two years ago, Batygin and Brown made a case for Planet Nine's existence (Evidence for a Distant Giant Planet in the Solar System) based on the peculiar orbits of a handful of distant worlds known as Kuiper belt objects.

That small population loops outward toward the same quadrant of the solar system, a phenomenon that would be extremely unlikely to happen by chance.

Batygin and Brown argued that a ninth planet must be shepherding those worlds into their strange orbits.

What's more, Batygin and Brown also predicted that over time, Planet Nine's gravity would push these Kuiper Belt objects out of their current plane and into ever-higher orbital inclinations.

Although astronomers have already spotted a bizarre population of worlds that orbit the sun perpendicularly to the plane of the solar system, they had never caught an object transitioning between the two populations.

"There's no real way to put something on an orbit like that - except that it's exactly what we predicted from Planet Nine," Brown said.

Batygin notes that the new object fits so perfectly with their model that it almost looks like one of the data points in their simulations.

"A good theory reproduces data - but a great theory predicts new data," he said.

Juliette Becker,

a doctoral student at the University of Michigan,

 led the analysis of the new object.
University of Michigan

The Dark Energy Survey first detected evidence for the new object in late 2014.

Gerdes and his colleagues have spent the years since then tracking its orbit and trying to understand its origins.

In the new paper, they describe how they ran many simulations of the object within the known solar system, letting the clock run forward and backward 4.5 billion years at a time.

Nothing could explain how the object landed in such a tilted orbit.

It wasn't until they added in a ninth planet - a planet with characteristics that perfectly match Batygin and Brown's predictions - that the wacky orbit finally made sense.

"The second you put Planet Nine in the simulations, not only can you form objects like this object, but you absolutely do," said Juliette Becker, a graduate student at Michigan and the lead author on the new paper.

A strong and sustained interaction with Planet Nine appears to be the only way to pump up the object's inclination, pushing it away from the plane of the solar system.

"There is no other reasonable way to populate the Kuiper belt with such highly inclined bodies," Batygin said.

 

"I think the case for the existence of Planet Nine is now genuinely excellent."

Other astronomers aren't so certain - in part because the early solar system remains a mystery.

Scientists suspect that the sun was born within a cluster of stars, meaning that the early planets might have had many close encounters with other stars that sent them on paths that seem impossible today.

And even once the stars dispersed, the early solar system likely contained tens of thousands of dwarf planets that could have provided the gravitational nudges needed to push 2015 BP519, as the new object is called, into such an odd orbit.

"To me, Planet Nine is one of a number of ways that the solar system could have unfolded," said Michele Bannister, an astronomer at Queen's University Belfast who was not involved in the study.

 

"It's a potential idea."

But at the moment it is just that - an idea...

Yet when astronomers examine the larger universe, the idea doesn't seem all that surprising.

Planets between two and 10 times the mass of Earth are incredibly common throughout the galaxy, which makes it odd that our solar system doesn't harbor one.

"If it wasn't in our own solar system - if the stakes weren't so high - I think that the hypothesis would almost certainly be correct," Laughlin said.

 

"It's only the fact that it's so amazing that tends to give me pause."

Finding a ninth planet within our solar system would be both transformative and extraordinarily inspiring, he said.

"It would be this dramatic confirmation of the scientific method, which would be pretty refreshing in the current age where the truth is on trial."