by Jagannath Chatterjee
April 13, 2019
Jagannath Chatterjee is a vaccine researcher and author
of a number of articles on the subject that have
appeared in newspapers and journals in India. He also
writes for websites.
campaigner of 30 years standing against vaccines he is a
vaccine victim being affected severely by the MMR
vaccine in 1979 when he was 17 and preparing for a
career in medicine.
unanswered questions about vaccine safety.
We need studies
on vaccinated populations
based on various schedules and doses
well as individual patient susceptibilities
that we are continuing
to learn about.
No one should be threatened by the pursuit of this
Vaccine policy should be the subject of frank and open
with no tolerance for bullying.
There are no sides
about the well being of our children."
Dr Bernadine Healy
MD, Former Director
National Institute of
On 17th January 2019 the WHO while unveiling its new 5 year
strategic plan, The 13th Global Program of Work, declared vaccine
hesitancy among global public health threats alongside Ebola. 1
21st March 2019 in a meeting at Geneva to decide the post 2020
vaccine strategy, it talked of deep and broad engagement of
stakeholders to take forward the vaccination agenda globally and Kate Gilmore, UN Dy
High Commissioner Human Rights, stated,
"There is no such
thing as the right to refuse vaccines." 2
The intent is to neutralize a growing movement that has been raising
critical questions regarding vaccines since the 18th century spurred
by a broad range of issues like,
mandates and breach of civil liberties
refusal to acknowledge
lack of oversight and unresolved issues on matters
of vaccine safety and efficacy
conflict of interest
the industry and regulating agencies
Vaccination has a controversial history. Prior to vaccination there
were three practices; olfaction, inoculation and variolation.
These failed because they
led to serious adverse effects, increased the death rate and helped
the disease to spread among populations where they were practiced.
Jenner's small pox vaccination was accepted upon a single case of
James Phipps who after operation in May 1796 survived a disease
challenge, deemed unethical by many, 4 and it was assumed
the immunity was for life.
However the incidence
rapidly increased and the promised period of immunity reduced
progressively from a lifetime to six months. Repeated revaccination
was suggested which suited those implementing the practice for a
handsome fee. 5
Opposition to the vaccine grew as people witnessed deaths and very
serious adverse effects from,
"the most dangerous vaccine" that Dr
Paul Offit acknowledges "has an adverse effect profile we would not
accept as a vaccine today". 6
An article in the JAMA attributes the
deaths to serious adverse effects and specifies not only those
vaccinated but the contacts too were coming down with the
Parents preferred to pay fines and even accept jail
terms rather than having their wards vaccinated, particularly as
they had previous children who had succumbed.
As adverse effects were ignored people organized to form
anti-vaccination groups. France banned vaccination after unrest in
Growing rejection of the vaccine and protests against it
led to mandates in 1853 in Leicester, England and protests led to
the launch of the Anti-Vaccination League in 1870. The
Anti-vaccination Society of America came up in 1879.
leagues, the New England Anti Compulsory Vaccination League (1882)
and the Anti-vaccination League of New York City (1885) followed.
In India Mahatma Gandhi opposed the small pox vaccine, advocated
measures adopted by Leicester and declared himself anti-vaccine.
In 1955 the Governor General
C Rajagopalachari published a booklet
titled, "BCG - Why I oppose it" leading to ICMR's Chingleput Trial
that proved the vaccine to "offer no overall protection".
The well organized and
documented Indian opposition to vaccination considered it to be a
fallacy, sacrilege, betrayal and conspiracy. 12
The members of the anti-vaccination groups were stalwarts from all
sections of society and received inputs from the medical profession
and public health officials who engaged in documenting vaccination
harm, designed pamphlets warning the public, analyzed statistics,
and submitted detailed petitions to governments against
Public meetings were held
where political leaders pointed out mandates went against the right
to liberty and bodily integrity; a point relevant to this day. 14
Protests led to results.
The Royal Commission gathered evidence for
seven years and repealed England's compulsory vaccination law in
1907. Statistical analysis showed the epidemics increased
dramatically after 1854 - the year the compulsory vaccination law
In England and Wales, 44,840 people died of smallpox
when official estimates showed 97 percent of the population were
By 1919, England and
Wales had become one of the least vaccinated countries and had only
28 deaths from smallpox out of a population of 37.8 million people.
In 1941 Dr. C. Killick Millard, Medical Officer of Health
(Leicester, England) published The Vaccination Question and
admitted that the city of Leicester, with a population of around
300,000 at the time, had for 30 years abandoned infantile
vaccination and yet miraculously experienced an enormous decline in
smallpox mortality. 17
The National Anti-Vaccination League of Britain exposed statistical
"The Ministry of Health has admitted that the vaccinal
condition is a guiding factor in diagnosis."
If a person who is
vaccinated comes down with the disease he was protected against, the
disease was recorded under another name.
rash and eczema were diagnostic options.
This increased the
efficacy of the vaccine. 18
The same phenomenon was observed in Philippines as recorded by
"In the Philippines,
prior to U.S. takeover in 1905, case mortality [death rate] from
smallpox was about 10%.
In 1918-1919, with
over 95% of the population vaccinated, the worst epidemic in the
Philippines' history occurred resulting in a case mortality of
The 1920 Report of
the Philippines Health Service stated 'hundreds of thousands of
people were yearly vaccinated with the most unfortunate result
that the 1918 epidemic looks prima facie as a flagrant failure
of the classic immunization toward future epidemics." 19
Many regions including Leicester rejected the vaccine and adopted
sanitation, hygiene, isolation and nutrition and the disease rate
declined remarkably. 20
Ironically small pox when
it disappeared all over the world disappeared also in regions where
people shunned the vaccine and adopted them. It is known the WHO
too was forced to adopt isolation, sanitation and hygiene alongside.
Incidentally what virus
was present in the vaccine still remains a mystery leaving the space
wide open for debate. 21
The anti-vaccination movement, its accusations and alternative
solutions were vindicated.
The wave of a future movement was sown in 1943 when Dr Leo Kanner,
a psychiatrist, made a case study of children who suffered from a
novel disorder he termed Autism.
Documenting details of
these thoroughly unresponsive children he mentioned they were
vaccinated for small pox and DPT. 22
However it was an epidemic of encephalopathy observed in children
leading to deaths and a lifetime of disability that spurred parents
in the USA to question vaccines again. Their anger was not
As early as 1933 the DPT vaccine was linked by Dr
to deaths in children. In 1947 Dr Brody linked it to brain damage. A
1948 study by Dr Byers et al linked it to deaths, blindness,
deafness, spasticity, convulsions, and other severe neurological
There was open admission of guilt by eminent
immunologists in a US TV show DPT: Vaccine Roulette by investigative
reporter Lea Thompson broadcast in 1982 where children who had
turned into vegetables after receiving the shots were also
The US vaccine industry faced bankruptcy paying
compensation to parents who went to the Court against them. The
manufacturers shifted to the acellular pertussis vaccine, the DTaP
as it was found the pertussis component was guilty. 25
The anti-vaccine crowd was proven right again...
This second wave was dealt with in the most brazen manner possible.
The industry approached the US government and pleaded they needed
protection or they would go out of business.
The government of
Ronald Reagan provided limited liability to vaccine manufacturers in
October 1986 and set up a federal compensation program 26 to be
funded by an excise duty on each vaccine component that would
ironically be borne by the purchaser. 27
As on February 2019 this program
has paid out $ 4.06 billion to 4,172 cases decided by a Vaccine
The New York Times of 15th November 1986 reported,
"The increase in
the cost of liability insurance and the unpredictable nature of such
liability has forced some manufacturers to consider abandoning
production of vaccines."
"Mr. Reagan's action came after heavy
lobbying in favor of the bill by a broad-based coalition including
drug companies, physicians." 29
There still remained a possibility that parents could opt out of the
system to sue manufacturers.
This loophole was blocked when the US
Supreme Court supported the US Congress view in the Bruesewitz v.
Wyeth case of 2011.
The Court judgment noted,
manufacturer shall be liable in a civil action for damages arising
from a vaccine-related injury or death associated with the
administration of a vaccine after October 1,1988, if the injury or
death resulted from side effects that were unavoidable even though
the vaccine was properly prepared and was accompanied by proper
directions and warnings." 30
In short it agreed that vaccines were
"unavoidably unsafe" and therefore awarded absolute immunity to
The pro-vaccination group won and left the industry with no
incentive or intention to produce safe and effective vaccines.
US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) was consequently
instructed to submit safety reports to the government every two
years acceding to public concerns.
The Informed Consent Action
Network (ICAN) and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. sued the US government in
an attempt to reveal the safety reports that received the response,
"The Departments search for records did not locate any records
responsive to your request". 31
According to a legal document
entitled, "Mandate for Safer Childhood Vaccines," Health and Human
Services (HHS) openly admitted,
"to not having filed
any vaccine safety reports in over 30 years!" 32
Thus vaccine safety
depends upon clinical trials of the manufacturers...
How capable are they for
revealing adverse effects?
"According to the
'2013 WHO Expert Consultation on the Use of Placebos in Vaccine
Trials', the following replacements are used in lieu of a true
"In place of a
placebo, a vaccine against a disease that is not the focus
of the trial is given to participants who do not receive the
...or, an "add-on"
vaccine can be used:
"In this design,
the trial vaccine or placebo product is mixed with an
existing vaccine not studied in the trial, and the subjects
are given either (a) the trial vaccine mixed with the
existing unrelated vaccine or (b) the combination of a
placebo and the existing unrelated vaccine."
Thus the trials can never
provide a genuine risk assessment. 33
The WHO admits:
"A methodological disadvantage, however, is that
trials using these types of placebos provide a less perfect control.
It may be difficult or impossible to assess fully the safety and reactogenicity of the trial vaccine."
The reasons offered are
vaccines are classified as biological - therefore they do not
require stringent safety tests, and it would be unethical to deny
the control group the use of a vaccine. 34
This is the same WHO which considers those questioning vaccines to
be the greatest public health threat, which has decided to launch a
vigorous grassroots campaign to promote vaccines involving all its
stakeholders and feels there should be no right to refuse.
Clinical trials are also known to obfuscate troublesome data.
September 2017, a report titled "Infanrix hexa and sudden death: a
review of the periodic safety update reports submitted to the
European Medicines Agency" published in the Indian Journal of
Medical Ethics 35 alleged that GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) apparently
excluded certain cases of infant deaths in their official report to
the European Medicines Agency.
GSK stated that the deaths reported
after the vaccine is "coincident" and not related to the vaccine.
However analysis by Puliyel and Sathyamala, authors, showed that 83%
of the reported deaths occurred within 10 days of vaccination and
another 17% occurred in the following ten days.
"Glossing over of
the deaths after vaccination has potential to result in more,
unnecessary deaths which are difficult to justify ethically," they
observed in a Press Release.
The same vaccine and an MMR vaccine have also been embroiled in
serious contamination scandals 36 and the list 37 grows by the
In yet another shocking incident the Government of India
preferred not to release clinical data of an indigenous Rotavirus
vaccine that showed a very high incidence of a potentially lethal
intestinal obstruction in vaccinated children 38 under
the plea that revealing the data would "alarm the public". 39
The third wave of the anti-vaccination movement was focused on
autism discovered in 1943.
It appeared in children all over the
globe and became unmanageable by the 1990's. The severity is
reflected by the fact that in California the prevalence increased
600% in the period 1990 - 2002. 40
It was the parents who raised
their voice only to be ridiculed and demonized. They were asked to
deny their own eyes as they watched and even video recorded their
children regress after taking vaccines.
A lot happened during this period. In 3rd April 2000, a study titled
"Autism, a novel form of mercury poisoning" by Sallie Bernard et al
found 200 symptoms of autism to exactly match mercury poisoning and
ascribed it to the use of the mercury containing compound Thiomersal
Published in Medical
Hypotheses in April 2001 after a thorough review, it created quite a
stir and was vehemently criticized. 41
The din refused to fade and became shriller still when a freedom of
information act petition by Congressman David Weldon exposed the
minutes of a high profile meeting of 51 officials belonging to the
CDC, vaccine manufacturers, and highly placed government officials
who had met in Simpsonwood, Northcross Georgia, USA on 7th-8th
June 2000 to discuss two CDC studies that found undeniable
association between mercury containing vaccines and autism.
relative risk found in both the studies was 7.62 42; any
figure above 1 being a sure indication. 43
CDC correspondence between the author Thomas Verstraeten and top
notch scientists revealed he had manipulated the data at his level
from a RR of 11.35 and unable to do so any further sent an SOS for
"The association will not go away."
Consequently the meeting
was held where the guests decided to bury the association even as a
member conceded his grandchild would not receive vaccines, another
expressed concerns over targets to be met, while a third highlighted
a similar role of the vaccine adjuvant aluminium which he felt had
equally disastrous consequences.
All of them agreed that
these results should not reach the public. 44
Verstraeten left the CDC to join the vaccine giant Glaxosmithkline,
and one study published in the November 2003 issue of the journal
"No consistent significant associations were
found between TCVs (thiomersal containing vaccines) and
neurodevelopmental outcomes. Conflicting results were found at
different HMOs for certain outcomes".
In short, nothing to
Researchers examined this and 15 other studies purporting
to show Thiomersal is safe and uncovered malfeasance and cover
ups. 46 The other Verstraeten study showing the same 7.62
association remains with the CDC and is available in its archives.
Faced with opposition the US Government decided in 1998 to remove
mercury in drugs and pharmaceutical products 47 but old stock was
allowed to be administered up to 2006.
Mercury was allowed to remain
as "trace amount" and vaccines like the Hep B and the
annual Flu vaccines continued to have 25mcg of mercury in them.
Researcher Neil Z Miller pointed out that yet another neurotoxin aluminium replaced mercury,
"Prior to the mercury phase-out
(pre-2000), babies received 3,925 micrograms (mcg) of aluminum in
their first year-and-a-half of life.
After pneumococcal and
hepatitis A vaccines were added to the immunization schedule, babies
began receiving 4,925 mcg of aluminum during the same age period - a
25% increase. In 2011, CDC recommended that pregnant women receive a pertussis vaccine (Tdap), which also contains aluminum.
that aluminum crosses the placenta and accumulates in fetal tissue.
Thus, millions of babies in utero, infants, and young children were
injected with, and continue to receive, unnaturally high doses of
neurotoxic substances - mercury and aluminum - long after
unsuspecting parents were led to believe that vaccines were
purified and made safe."
In developing nations the
mercury compound continues to be present in all non live virus
vaccines on the plea removing mercury would make vaccines costlier.
CDC provided a grant to Dr Poul Thorsen of Denmark to conduct the
famous Danish studies.
They found that Thiomersal in vaccines and
the MMR vaccine were not associated with autism. The studies came
under a cloud when a CDC insider squealed that Dr Thorsen had
misappropriated the grant.
The case was investigated and Thorsen
was found guilty of 22 counts of money laundering and wire fraud in
April 2011. 50
US Attorney Quillian Yates remarked,
"This defendant is
alleged to have orchestrated a scheme to steal over $1 million
in CDC grant money earmarked for autism research. We will now
seek the defendants extradition." 51
Thorsen remains on the "Most Wanted" list of the
Office of Inspector General, US DHHS, and awaits extradition as
Denmark does not have an extradition treaty with the US. 52
feels his financial misdemeanor has not affected his scientific
integrity and defends the studies.
Another investigation was conducted on September 18, 2017.
evidence, uncovered by Children's Health Defense, showed that Thorsen and his collaborators did not obtain permission from an
Institutional Review Board (IRB) to conduct their research, which
was published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2002 and
Pediatrics in 2003.
In 2009, when CDC discovered that Thorsen never
applied for the IRB approvals, staff did not report the errors and
retract the studies.
documents show that CDC supervisors ignored the missteps and
covered up the illegal activity." 53
The next CDC study to run into a controversy was when Dr
Thompson, CDC Immunization Safety Researcher, turned whistleblower
and handed over 10,000 documents he was asked to destroy to the US
Congress that revealed gross incongruities in the CDC DeStefano
study published in 2002 that investigated the role of MMR vaccines
in autism in a bid to refute the 1998 investigation by Dr
After Dr. Brian Hooker's requests through the
Information Act for original MMR study documentation Dr. Thompson,
the co-author, buckled under the pressure of his conscience to hand
over documents he was asked to destroy that demonstrated a 3.4 fold
increase in the incidence of autism in African American boys,
expunged from the final study results in an act of scientific
Dr Brian Hooker
accessed the raw data to confirm the allegations. The matter is
currently under Congress investigation. 55
The studies that strongly deny the vaccine autism connection are
thus weak in their foundations. It must also trouble us that of the
cases of vaccine injury compensated under NVICP, there exist 85
cases of autism awarded for encephalopathy. 56 The association is
denied under the plea that they only resemble symptoms of autism.
But autism is a symptomatic diagnosis.
In 13th January 2019 The Hill reported,
neurologist Dr. Andrew Zimmerman who originally served as the
expert medical witness for the government, which defends
vaccines in federal vaccine court signed a sworn affidavit.
During a group of
5,000 vaccine-autism cases being heard in court on June 15,
2007, he took aside the Department of Justice (DOJ) lawyers he
worked for defending vaccines and told them he'd discovered
'exceptions' in which vaccinations could cause autism.
"I explained that
in a subset of children, vaccine-induced fever and immune
stimulation did cause regressive brain disease with features
of autism spectrum disorder."
His opinion was based
on scientific advances and his own experience with patients."
However his confession
was disregarded and the cases dismissed. 57
The anti-vaccine movement spread worldwide when the HPV vaccine
against cervical cancer introduced in 2007 became associated with
clinical trial fraud, and numerous cases of deaths and serious
These cases received huge media publicity in Japan,
Sweden, UK, Ireland and the USA.
The vaccine adverse effect
reporting system (VAERS) of the USA accessed by Sanevax reveals up
to 14th March 2019, 61,552 adverse events that include 480 deaths
and 9070 cases classified as serious. 58
It is estimated that VAERS
records 1 to 10% of actual. 59
Activists in India filed a case which was admitted in the Supreme
Court in January 2013 when it emerged that PATH and the ICMR had
conducted an illegal clinical trial in the year 2009 that killed
seven tribal girls and sickened almost every girl that it was
administered to defying informed consent norms and local laws.
Afrikaners were jolted in November 2014 when the Catholic Doctors
Association found evidence from reports of nine accredited
laboratories that beta hcg, a birth control hormone, was present in
tetanus vaccines being used by WHO and UNICEF in Kenya targeting 14
to 49 year old women.
"In February 2018 the Kenyan president Raila
Odinga made a public televised statement acknowledging a tetanus
vaccine given in 2014-2015 to approximately 500,000 women was
confirmed to contain a sterilization hormone.
The licence of the
manufacturer was cancelled." 61
In 2017 Philippines erupted in anger when it was revealed that the
Dengue vaccine manufactured by Sanofi approved in the country and
administered to 800,000 children had ignored a warning it could
increase the cases of severe dengue in persons previously exposed to
The official death toll is 154 as on Sept 26, 2018.
hemorrhage has been found in many cases.
authorities have revealed there is a clear case against six Sanofi
officials, mostly country representatives of the firm, and 14
current and former Philippine health officials including former
Health Minister Janette Garin for 10 confirmed deaths." 63
Meanwhile the parents of the 800,000 children and 100,000 more in
Brazil dread the day their wards would come down with dengue.
What is the strategy being used to push vaccines into an
increasingly unwilling population?
It starts with naming vaccines to
be "immunization" whereas 100% of the suffering population can turn
out to be "fully immunized" 64 and the discovery of cell mediated
immunity by Merrill Chase in 1942 has all but negated this
Portraying vaccines to be about "public health" and
"preventive medicine" when vaccines have been linked so far to 248
diseases and disabilities including death by scientific published
studies, 66 and research proves most infectious diseases have
therapeutic benefits. 67
The concept of "herd
immunity" used to jack up vaccination rates has been argued to be a
"dishonest marketing gimmick". 68
The study of
the human microbiome points to the fact that vaccines
and antibiotics can lead to a whole host of illnesses.
Prof Ruth Ley
remarks on the BBC,
"Where work on the microbiome comes in is seeing
how changes in the microbiome, that happened as a result of the
success we've had fighting pathogens(with antibiotics and vaccines),
have now contributed to a whole new set of diseases that we have to
deal with." 69
A study in April 2018 found that environmental
genetic changes termed epigenetic changes can travel 14
Is it a wonder that people turn against
What should be done to stem the crisis?
Dr Pushpa Mittra Bhargava,
founder director of The Institute of Cellular and Molecular Biology,
had suggested some steps to the author to ensure safe vaccination
programs when he was interviewed in the year 2009 at Secunderabad.
There is a system for introducing vaccines into India. Many factors
have to be considered.
What is the incidence of the disease in the
country; are there some regions where it is concentrated? Does the
incidence justify a vaccine?
"What is the mortality rate from the disease? Is it high enough to
justify a vaccine? What is the safety profile of the vaccine? Has it
been tested on Indian populations and found safe?
What safety issues
are being ignored? What are the alternatives to the vaccine? Can
other safer public health measures control the disease better than
the vaccine? Is the disease easily treatable at a lesser cost?
Vaccines are a costly measure as they also involve logistics and
staff to administer. Is there a cost benefit in using the vaccine or
by avoiding it?
"Who are the children who should receive the vaccine and who should
not? What are the contraindications of the vaccine? Must the vaccine
be given to all or can it be restricted to regions of high
Is there a mechanism in place to monitor the above
process that consists of capable members free from conflict of
interest? Is there a system of monitoring adverse effects and
addressing them in a transparent manner and which too is free from
conflict of interest?
Is there pressure from international agencies
to introduce the vaccine and influence the process?
"All these are important non negotiable issues whenever a vaccine is
introduced into the country. I protested the oral polio vaccine
because it is a hasty decision considering that the vaccine has a
history of causing paralysis.
We also do not know how it will affect
the gut microbes. Are the cases of encephalitis we are witnessing in
regions where intensive drives are on because of the vaccine?
"I am not opposed to vaccines but systems and procedures
must be in place if we are to behave responsibly. Vaccines
cannot be included in any schedule simply because someone
somewhere is manufacturing them." 71
These sage words must reverberate in all members of the scientific
community who are interested in vaccine safety.
We are aware of
vaccination warnings being ignored in India.
Dr Vipin Vashishtha,
senior executive committee member of the IAP voiced his concern
about 15 additional vaccines being given by IAP members and that,
money is corrupting pediatrics academy". 72
He alleged that the
amount of Rs. 25,000 to 30,000 per child that led to annual revenue
of Rs. 8100 crores was driving the urge to vaccinate. 73
Dr Vashistha was physically assaulted at an IAP function
expelled from the IAP for raising his voice. 75
Doctors in India have expressed concerns about the Pentavalent
vaccine in the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics, and suggested it
could be behind around 8100 deaths annually in Indian children.
WHO responded to the global reports of deaths by revising the
reporting system such that the deaths could not be ascribed to the
vaccine making Dr Jacob Puliyel lament,
"Even deaths are no
longer a contraindication to vaccination." 76
An RTI query in 2018 made the Indian government concede 10,612
deaths after vaccinations provided under the universal immunization
program from 2008 to 2018. 77
It also revealed upwards of 600,000
adverse effects are reported every year.
Government officials hint
at coincidence. The OPV vaccine being given with religious fervour
in India has been attributed to 491,704 cases of paralysis in Indian
children from 2000 to 2017 and the criticism against the study
methodology has been countered effectively. 78
Such figures do not
inspire confidence, nor does the response. The private sector in
India that vaccinates 2.7 million children or more annually has no
Parents in India have approached two High Courts,
...after children started dying and were hospitalized in hordes
after being vaccinated with the measles rubella vaccine in a school
Deciding on the petitions the clear
both cases has been, the parents can object to vaccination 79 and
that the risks have to be revealed and informed written consent
Preparations are on to
challenge the decisions. It has been acknowledged by government
sources that vaccination campaigns cannot succeed unless the parents
are kept ignorant and the vaccines forced on the children. 81
Our children are today in a deplorable state.
According to a report,
54% of children
today suffer from chronic disorders 82
1 in 10
children have asthma
1 in 13 suffers from food allergies
1 in 6
children suffer from developmental disorders
1 in 8 suffers severe
The CDC's latest report released in April
2019 reveals 1 in 59 children suffer autism. 83
In the past 8 to 10
juvenile diabetes increased by 23%
cancer increased by 29%
ADHD increased by 43%
food allergies increased by 50%
rose by almost 50%
Where is the healthy
childhood that vaccines promised?
All independent studies
that have compared the health of vaccinated and non- vaccinated so
far have found the non-vaccinated groups to be healthier on all
counts studied. 85
The collusion between the WHO, big philanthropies, the vaccination
industry and the media cannot be denied. 86
FDA medical advisor
"The (US) Congress is owned by Pharma".
vaccine industry that has paid billions of dollars in fines and is
involved in felonies be trusted? Can the CDC that holds 50 vaccine
patents and has a for profit wing be an impartial body free from
conflict of interest when it recommends vaccines? 88
The industry on record
donates to political parties to lobby for vaccine mandates. 89
Must a campaign that raises crucial issues, seeks scientific
interventions, and expects the medical profession to ensure health
be attacked just for being anti-industry?
We can no longer ignore the elephant in the room. Vaccination
mandates being imposed in the USA in response to anti-vaccination
sentiments and the censoring of social media is not the solution.
The scientific society must proceed on observation, evidence and
facts and not be swayed by the manipulations of the vaccine industry
and its lobbyists. History will judge the custodians of children
according to what their response will be at the present moment.
that decision be sane and scientific. We need courage and
determination to face the bullies.
Our children are precious, not
the profits of an industry that stands exposed.
threats to global health in 2019, WHO. https://www.who.int/emergencies/ten-threats-to-global-health-in-2019
Stakeholders Meet to Establish a "Different Approach" for
Post 2020 Vaccine Strategy, Health Policy Watch. https://www.healthpolicy-watch.org/who-stakeholders-meet-to-establish-a-different-approach-for...
a great and Terrible Scourge, History of Medicine. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/smallpox/sp_variolation.html
Jenner's small pox experiment pass a research ethics
on Immunity, Vaccinations and Smallpox, Phillip Incao, MD. http://www.vaccineinfo.net/immunization/how_vaccines_work.shtml
Dangerous Vaccine, CBS News. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-most-dangerous-vaccine/
Attributable to Small Pox Vaccination, JAMA. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/353655
Vaccination Movement. https://measlesrubellainitiative.org/anti-vaccination-movement/
Anti Vaccination Movement. https://www.historyofvaccines.org/index.php/content/articles/history-anti...
Diseases; Small Pox, Guide to health, Mahatma Gandhi. https://currenthealthscenario.blogspot.com/2018/10/...
year follow up of trial of BCG vaccines in south India for
tuberculosis prevention. Tuberculosis Research Centre (ICMR),
Chennai. Indian Journal of Medical Research. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10573656
sacrilege, betrayal, and conspiracy. The cultural
construction of opposition to immunization in India. Niels
Vaccination Exposed and Illustrated; Petition to the
President to Abolish Compulsory Vaccination in Army and
Navy, Charles M Higgins, MD. https://www.amazon.com/Horrors-Vaccination-Exposed-Illustrated-Compulsory/dp/0243071949
Policies and Human Rights, Marry Holland. http://www.firstfreedoms.org/vaccination-policies...
Setting the Record Straight, Idaho Observer. http://proliberty.com/observer/20000607.htm
Vaccine: Origins of vaccine madness, Jennifer Craig, Phd
Vaccination Question in the Light of Modern Experience, Dr C
Killick Millard. https://books.google.co.in/books/about/The_Vaccination_Question_in_the_Light_of.html
Setting the Record Straight, Idaho Observer. http://proliberty.com/observer/20000607.htm
The "Hidden" Facts by Ian Sinclair
Sanitation versus Vaccination, J T Biggs, Sanitary
vaccine saved billions of lives, yet scientists had no idea
what virus they used in it, Newsweek, https://www.newsweek.com/genome-sequencing-smallpox-vaccine-shows-not-cowpox-682793
Theory of Vaccine Induced Autism Did Not Begin With Andrew
Wakefield, Ginger Taylor. https://adventuresinautism.blogspot.com/2018/07/no-theory-of-vaccine-induced-autism-did.html
DPT - A
shot in the dark, Harris Coulter, Barbara Fisher. https://www.amazon.in/Dpt-Shot-Harris-L-...
on Vaccines Stirs Bitter Controversy, Donna Hilts, https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/local/1982/04/28/...
What is the
history of pertussis vaccine use in America? NVIC. https://www.nvic.org/vaccines-and-diseases/whooping-cough/vaccine-history.aspx
National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986, 99th Congress
need to know about the vaccine injury compensation programme. https://www.hrsa.gov/sites/default/files/vaccinecompensation/resources/84521booklet.pdf
and Statistics. https://www.hrsa.gov/sites/default/files/hrsa/vaccine-compensation/data...
SIGNS BILL ON DRUG EXPORTS AND PAYMENT FOR VACCINE
PEAR, NEW YORK TIMES NOV. 15, 1986. https://www.nytimes.com/1986/11/15/us/reagan-signs-bill-on-...
Court, Bruesewitz v. Wyeth case of 2011 https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/10pdf/09-152.pdf
Order. Informed Consent Action Network vs US Department of
Health and Human Services Stipulation. http://icandecide.org/government/ICAN-HHS-Stipulated-Order-July-2018.pdf
Why Kennedy Sued the Government Over Vaccine Safety & Won. https://www.aimintegrativemedicine.com/aim-...
Consultation on the Use of Placebos in Vaccine Trials. https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/94056/9789241506250_eng.pdf
hexa and sudden death: a review of the periodic safety
update reports submitted to the European Medicines Agency. https://ijme.in/articles/infanrix-hexa-and-sudden-death-a-review-of-the-periodic-safety-update-reports-...
of Italy. Banjot Kaur. Down to Earth. https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/health/the-vaccinegate-of-italy-63235
Vaccinegate-2: What did
we find in the MMRV (Priorix Tetra) vaccine? https://www.corvelva.it/en/speciale-corvelva/...
cytomegalovirus and contamination of oral poliovirus
Rotavirus Vaccine Trial Data not Forthcoming. Jagannath
Court Told: "Releasing Vaccine Data Would Alarm Public"!
Jagannath Chatterjee. https://www.vaccinationinformationnetwork.com/indian-court-told-releasing-...
Disappearing Seasonality of Autism Conceptions in
California, Soumya mazumdar et al. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3408493/
novel form of mercury poisoning, S.BernardA.EnayatiL.RedwoodH.RogerT.Binstock, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article...
Review of Verstraeten's "Generation Zero" VSD Study Results,
: 1999-2000: Simpsonwood. http://putchildrenfirst.org/chapter2.html
thimerosal-containing vaccines: a two-phased study of
computerized health maintenance organization databases.
Verstraeten T et al. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14595043
Methodological Issues and Evidence of Malfeasance in
Research Purporting to Show Thimerosal in Vaccines Is Safe,
Brian Hooker et al, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4065774/
Asleep at the Switch Again - An Ongoing Saga , Children
argue to keep thiomersal in some vaccines. Alexandra
Metal. Down to Earth. https://www.downtoearth.org.in/indepth/heavy-metal-7574
Doctors appeal for
mercury free vaccines. https://www.moneylife.in/article/doctors-appeal-for-mercury-free-vaccines/39289.html
RESEARCHER INDICTED FOR STEALING GRANT MONEY. https://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/gan/press/2011/04-13-11.html
profiles, US DHHS. https://oig.hhs.gov/fraud/fugitives/profiles.asp
Conduct - Poul Thorsen, Children Health Defense.
Scientist: ‘We scheduled meeting to destroy vaccine-autism
study documents', Sharyl Attkisson. https://sharylattkisson.com/2016/03/cdc-scientist-we-scheduled-meeting-to-destroy-vaccine-autism-study-documents/
Whistleblower: Exposing Autism Research Fraud at the CDC,
Kevin Berry, Dr Boyd E Haley. https://www.amazon.com/Vaccine-Whistleblower-Exposing-Autism-Research/dp/1634509951
Court Compensated 83 Vaccine-Injured Autistic Children. AHRP. https://ahrp.org/federal-court-compensated-83-vaccine-injured-autistic-children/
Vaccine Court Awards
Millions to Two Children With Autism. Huffington Post. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/post...
pro-vaccine doctor reopened debate about link to autism https://thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/425061-how-a-pro-vaccine-doctor-reopened-debate-about-link-to-autism
www.sanevax.org accessed on 25th April 2019
estimated that only 1-10%of all [vaccine] adverse reactions
are ever reported to VAERS.
Supreme Court Vaccine Controversy Continues. Norma
India: HPV vaccines
Gardasil and Cervarix make it to the Supreme Court. Press
HCG Found in WHO Tetanus Vaccine in Kenya Raises Concern in
the Developing World
Pharma Co Has License
Suspended as Vaccine Blamed For Sterilization of 500,000
Women & Children. Matt Agorist. http://thefreethoughtproject.com/pharma-co-vaccine-license-sterilization/
19 out of
154 children died from Dengue despite Dengvaxia shot. https://www.rappler.com/nation/212904-doh-report-number-children-dead-dengue-dengvaxia-shot-september-2018
to charge officials of Sanofi, government over dengue
vaccine.Karen Lema. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-sanofi-fr-philippines/philippines-to-charge-officials-of-sanofi-government-over-dengue-vaccine-idUSKCN1QI41L
outbreak in a fully immunized secondary-school population.
Gustafson TS et al. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3821823
(1942). British Society for Immunology. https://www.immunology.org/guinea-pig-1942
of published studies. Accessed 25th april 2019. www.greenmedinfo.com/anti-therapeutic-action/vaccination-all
childhood diseases like chickenpox and measles prevent
Immunity"? A dishonest marketing gimmick. J B Handley. https://childrenshealthdefense.org/news/herd-immunity-a-dishonest-marketing-gimmick/
half of your body is not human. James Gallagher. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/health-43674270
have observed epigenetic memories being passed down 14
generations. Signe Dean. https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-observe-epigenetic-memories-passed-down-for-14-generations-most-animal
does an Indian medical scientist think about vaccines? https://currenthealthscenario.blogspot.com/2019/01/what-does-indian-medical-scientist.html
money is corrupting paediatrics academy," Outlook. https://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/pharma-money-is-corrupting-paediatrics-academy/298720
vendors greed gone viral. Arushi Bedi. Outlook. https://www.outlookindia.com/magazine/story/vaccine-vendors-greed-gone-viral/298718
Nexus: Whistleblower Bengaluru Pediatrician seeks police
Pediatrician suspended from IAP for raising his voice
against nexus between vaccine manufacturers and doctors.
India Medical Times. http://www.indiamedicaltimes.com/2017/01/22/dr-vipin-vashishtha-suspended-from-iap-after-raising-voice-against-alleged-nexus-between-vaccine-manufacturers-and-doctors/
the Pentavalent vaccine. Dr Jacob Puliyel. https://ijme.in/articles/aefi-and-the-pentavalent-vaccine-looking-for-a-composite-picture/
mortality: Post immunisation issues led to 10,612 deaths in
10 years. Sadguru Pandit. https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/complications-after-immunisation-caused-10612-child-deaths-nationally-in-ten-years/story-xcfl8rC64dPshC2ofguIZO.html
drops linked to paralysis in India. Ranjit Devraj. https://www.scidev.net/asia-pacific/disease/news/oral-polio-drops-linked-to-paralysis-in-india.html
opt out of MR vaccination at school: HC. Mahir Haneef. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kochi/parents-can-opt-out-of-mr-vaccination-at-school-hc/articleshow/62087376.cms
consent needed for measles vaccination, Court tells
miss vaccine target over consent rider. Annonna Dutt. https://www.hindustantimes.com/delhi-news/delhi-may-miss-vaccine-target-over-consent-rider/story-L7lED4XjcrQGC68M7I7nAI.html
and State Profile of Leading Health Problems and Health Care
Quality for US Children: Key Insurance Disparities and
Across-State Variations. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1876285910002500
Report Shows Autism is Still on the Rise. Ed Cara. https://gizmodo.com/new-cdc-report-shows-autism-is-still-on-the-rise-1833979444
of Chronic Disease in Our Children. https://www.healthfreedomidaho.org/chronic
prove without doubt that unvaccinated children are far
healthier than their unvaccinated peers. England. https://vactruth.com/2014/02/26/unvaccinated-children-healthier/
Pilot comparative study
on the health of vaccinated and unvaccinated 6- to 12- year
old U.S. children. Anthony R Mawson et al. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317086531_Pilot_comparative_study...
Gates & Government: Who's Calling the Shots? https://www.nvic.org/nvic-vaccine-news/january-2019/who,-pharma,-gates.aspx
adviser: 'Congress is owned by pharma', Adrianna Belmonte.
The CDC Is
A For-Profit Corporation, Owning More Than 50 Different
Vaccine Patents https://www.march-against-monsanto.com/the-cdc-is-a-for-profit-corporation-owning-more-than-50-different-vaccine-patents/
companies donated millions to California lawmakers before
vaccine debate, Jim Miller. https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article24913978.html