|
by A Lily Bit September 01, 2026 from ALilyBit Website Information sent by Important Info Economics
became ESG, the Sustainable Development Goals, and the machine running your economy right now...
Klaus Schwab, the World Economic Forum (WEF), environmental, social, and governance scoring, the Great Reset, the whole traveling carnival. But I kept leaving out the one thing that would have made sense of the rest, which is that stakeholder capitalism is a subsidiary. It is not the beast.
It is one room inside the beast.
Now, you can build a critical theory out of anything on earth, given an afternoon and a grievance. The trick is to flip the frame over to systemic responsibility, and once you do, blame stops sitting on the actor and streams out into a web of everybody and everything connected to whatever it is you have decided to hate.
Take an example. No child should die because a car hits an elk on a dark road. Terrible thing, agreed.
But without
a driving culture, and without forests, and without free-roaming
elk, that child is alive, so the driving culture is complicit, and
the forest is complicit, and the elk, poor dumb animal, the elk is
complicit too, and so is everything that props any of it up. That
took me four sentences. It's dumb, it's over-simplified, it makes
absolutely no sense - yet it is a textbook critical theory.
Nike makes shoes, the shoes carry a strange
cultural charge for certain groups of people, and somewhere kids in
a rough stretch of the Bronx put bullets in each other over a pair
of Air Jordans, so on this reasoning Nike now owes a duty to the
stakeholders in that neighborhood. The model does not just permit
that conclusion. It sprints toward it, arms out, delighted.
And yet the corporation still needs running.
Somebody has to sit in the chair. So the pitch
shifts under your feet while you are looking the other way, and now
you answer to your shareholders, who have dividends waiting, and you
also answer to a fresh caste of political officers, certified
experts in the various fields of impact, who would like a word about
whether your air pollution is bad for the climate, or for
breathability, or for whatever landed in the officer's portfolio
between last quarter and this one.
Lynn Forester de Rothschild runs it, in partnership with the Vatican and, while he lived, Pope Francis, alongside more than seven hundred of the largest corporate leaders alive. Seven hundred of the thousand biggest corporations on the planet hold a membership card.
This council proposes to decide how capitalists and industry leaders ought to behave, inside their own companies, in order to qualify for a policy of inclusion, with its ever-lengthening list of stakeholders and marginalized groups and whatever else happens to be fashionable on the morning they hold the meeting. That is a wolf in the same coat a shepherd wears. A regulatory environment with reasonable regulations is one animal.
A control mechanism dressed in the language of
broader responsibility to a longer list of stakeholders is a very
different animal, and stakeholderism is the second one, every time
you lift the coat.
Did Schwab squeeze this idea out of his own turtle head? I have my doubts.
He took a master's at Harvard, business and
management of some flavor, and his advisor there answered to the
name Henry Kissinger. Kissinger may well have handed him the whole
thing gift-wrapped with a card.
BlackRock, run by Lawrence Fink, Larry if you want to be personal with his sodden face. State Street. Vanguard.
These enormous firms read the grades and decide
which stocks make the cut, which means they sit there with a scoring
sheet and decide how capital moves across the whole of the world
economy. That is ESG in a single paragraph, and it should frighten
you more than it does.
Heads of state by the handful:
These are the parasites crawling all over the World Economic Forum, and these are the people we have agreed to call experts.
They decide how all business shall run, and ESG
becomes the enforcement arm that reaches down through the investment
firms and squeezes.
The council rules on social governance and
economic governance and business governance and environmental
governance, and it dictates the terms on which businesses may
operate. The words in fashion this season are transition and
resilience, both lovely, both meaningless in the right hands.
There is nothing else in the box.
So it is a tyrannical system administered through corporate leaders, and it stays tolerable for those leaders exactly as long as they stay on the page.
None of this is new, which is the thing I most want to land on you. It is much older than the Forum and it has worn several names. Stakeholder socialism has been run. Stakeholder fascism has been run. Stakeholder corporatism has been run, and it works best of the three, because the arrangement is corporatist in the precise sense Benito Mussolini meant, the fusion of the corporation and the state.
That was the fascist economic model, corporate interests and everything else in the country lashed together, which is what the word fascism actually says, the binding of the sticks, lashed together in the interest of the state.
The state becomes the stakeholder group.
The Chinese Communist Party runs this model
today, right now, while you read.
The two systems are a political system that stays
communist right down to the marrow and lives inside the CCP, on
which point they will look you in the eye and say so, and an
economic system that runs on an entirely different set of rules.
Socialist theory cannot unleash the forces of
production. It turns out the thing is not hard, it is impossible,
and the men in Beijing know it is impossible. Which is why Deng
does what he does.
Cross the CCP and it repossesses. Say the wrong sentence at the wrong banquet and it repossesses. But play ball with the primary stakeholder group, which markets itself under the name Chinese Communist Party, and you may ascend to the ranks of what the movie called filthy rich Asians, and you get to stay filthy rich for precisely as long as you keep playing ball, and not one hour past that.
The primary stakeholder is the CCP, and it never
forgets which of you it made.
As Lenin said:
Socialism is the on-ramp. That is its entire
reason for being.
So, the system China runs today is not purely communist. It is a hybrid, and it borrowed selectively from national socialism, which is the clever bit, taking the parts that worked and quietly leaving the parts that turned out to be suicidal. It carries no plan to conquer territory by war and build an empire, because that particular ambition is exactly what put Nazi Germany in the ground.
What it kept was the economic program, and the economic program is the fascist model, and the fascist model, read with the lights on, is the stakeholder model.
Stakeholderism is what China runs. The CCP,
now under Xi Jinping, occupies the same chair the fascist
governments of the twentieth century occupied for their own
countries, and it has upholstered it nicely.
The route it takes to get there, and the precise
contents of the program on any given Christmas dinner, matter a
great deal less than the fact of universal adoption, which is the
real objective, and we adopt universally because, well, how dare you
not adore the noble goals of this program, what kind of person are
you.
It is the relationship to totalitarianism, and that relationship is not even coy about itself. Once you are seated on the stakeholder model, the stakeholder groups decide how business is done, and once you bolt on a social credit system they also decide how individuals order their own affairs.
Governing councils of unelected, unaccountable, self-appointed rulers, selected for a blend of ideological compliance and demonstrated loyalty and, since we are being grown-ups, blackmail, get to decide for everybody how to arrange their lives in service of a thing they call the common good.
Those councils run the economy, and everything hanging off the economy, which is to say your social behavior and your ability to buy a sandwich. They make full use of private property while compelling corporate persons to do with that property whatever the councils require.
They post political officers inside corporate governance to keep the spine straight. They tilt the incentives until corporations become the mules hauling the totalitarian agenda up the mountain, the whole thing organized as an oligarchy with a few gargantuan corporate winners whose representatives sit on the governing council beside other partners, some of them heads of state, who then press the program downhill onto the rest of us.
No individual keeps a shred of control. Total
oligarchy.
The West, though, the West is still free - at least on paper - and freedom is precisely what makes it the target. The West is tilting toward totalitarianism without yet living under a totalitarian government, even though its corporations already do.
Council for Inclusive Capitalism, ESG,
sustainable development, transition investing, and on down the
vocabulary list, which never runs dry, because they hire people
whose entire job is to keep it stocked.
Shareholder primacy walks out one door. Stakeholder
governance comes in the other.
Grow a company big enough and everyone is somehow a stakeholder, which means no one is, which means expert stakeholders have to be appointed, and appointed means unaccountable, unelected people with a mandate they gave themselves. The rhyme with communism is close enough to make your scalp prickle.
Under communism everything is done in the name of
the people. Under stakeholderism everything will be done in the name
of the stakeholders.
The commissars and the soviets decide how the world turns, and they decide by communist theory and the Bolshevik playbook, in which the greater good and the common good and the common welfare and the far-off arrival of communism in a communist state stand in for any concern about one living, breathing, hungry human being.
And a scheme like that always, without exception, needs specialists. Lenin's specialists were expert in Marxist theory and socialist praxis, credentialed to determine what serves the abstraction called the people and to impose it on the people's behalf, which was awfully generous of them.
The same playbook applies today.
***
And the park says otherwise, and we listen to the park, because of course we do.
There is a control room. There is a fence schedule. There is a confident assurance that the animals cannot get out. The worried ones are inside the building, the game warden, the mathematician, the vet, and they are told there will be no insubordination, because the systems are proprietary and the information is restricted, since a nervous investor might pull his money and a nervous guest might file suit, and it is to the guests, after all, that the whole enterprise swears its responsibility ultimately belongs.
There is your stakeholder model in one frame: a
group in a control room, in the rain, speaking warmly about the very
people the fences are thirty minutes from failing to protect.
It is run by whoever owns the control room, and
that group keeps the gates locked and the incident reports quiet and
the language about the guests warm and rounded, right up until the
moment the fences come down and there is a great deal of running and
screaming. And how I hate being right all the time.
These groups and the faces in them never seem to leave the stage, because nothing waiting in the wings can hold them to account.
They decide what the common good looks like and what the rest of us owe to bring it about. Two weeks to slow the spread. Flatten the curve. Wear a mask. Hand over your assets.
From there it is a short and well-lit walk to the Soviet model, and the only real difference is that the Soviets followed Bolshevik ideology out in the open, with the state as the sole corporation.
The model itself will burn any fuel you pour into it, through corporations that already exist, pushing whatever ideology its operators feel like making work this decade.
***
The danger is not that it is environmental, social, and governance policy. The danger is that the council decides what counts as good environmental, social, and governance policy. There is the hinge the whole thing swings on. They can rule one way on Monday and the opposite way on Thursday, and you have no move except to jump.
Point out, reasonably, that this is not what they said last quarter, and their faces go smooth as a pond. They can pull your license. They can brand you insubordinate. They can announce that you have failed to understand the assignment. They can strike your listing from their index. Their toolbox is deep.
So when they say jump, the only intelligent
question is how high, and you ask it on the way up, mid-air, cap in
hand.
Own the model and the contents become editable at
leisure, swapped out like a window display. Install the stakeholder
model and you are holding the machinery to exercise arbitrary power
over corporations and over individuals, and arbitrary power of that
shape is a definition of tyranny that needs no tailoring, it fits
straight off the rack.
Then things start to go wrong, as things do, and
the leaders blame outsiders and pull more power toward themselves to
fix the mess they made. That is the assembly line that manufactures
totalitarianism, and it has never once produced anything else.
The answer is stakeholderism. Two layers are worth reaching, and I will name them before setting out, since the route between them wanders.
The overarching model holds steady across both.
Whatever ideology it is hauling this particular
month is the least interesting cargo on the truck.
***
Stakeholderism keeps surfacing all through the volume, the way a body keeps surfacing in a lake, because it is a model of corporate governance and it has been a recurring headache across the twentieth century and into ours. My own hunch is that it has always been sitting on the shelf, waiting.
Back in the days of kings, the king held
stakeholder control over the corporations, and the pattern returns
like a bad tenant. Chapter four covers its first major legal
implementation in the modern era.
Corporate governance drifts away from the shareholders and out toward everybody holding a figurative stake, and figurative, in practice, is a synonym for everybody who breathes.
Hitler ran three categories of person.
Citizens. Aliens. And a third category he called subjects of the
state, who held the same rights as aliens, which is to say precious
few, and not a favorable place to find yourself standing when the
music stops. After 1937, the Volk and the Reich became the major
stakeholders in German corporate law.
Point four is the one that carries the poison.
The stakeholder becomes the German Reich, and the mechanism that
executes its will is the hierarchical leadership structure called
the leader principle. Keep four in your pocket.
You are allowed to get rich, absolutely, you get rich the moment your corporation has satisfied, in the sight of the Reich speaking on behalf of the Volk, its common good objectives, whatever the Reich has decided those objectives are on that particular morning.
Then you are free to go off and get rich doing whatever else amuses you, and if you can manage to get rich while serving the common good, so much the better, they will pin a ribbon on you. The sequence is the entire argument. Individual gain rides in the back seat.
You do not build a company to make your way in
the world. You build a company to improve the society, and improving
the society has to be the reason you got up in the morning.
In the second volume of Mein Kampf, Hitler argues that parliaments squander time and grind along inefficiently, and he offers a different model of state organization to replace them. There is a leader, the Führer.
Everyone obeys the leader. Below him sit subordinates, and each subordinate is himself a Führer over his own patch, obeyed by everyone beneath him, and below that tier sits another tier of little Führers, each obeyed by everyone under him, and so on down. A pyramid, with Adolf Hitler at the point of it. His word is law.
More than that, his word rides above the law,
above all written law, and he may rewrite it whenever the mood takes
him.
That is Schmitt, and Schmitt, the crown jurist of
the Third Reich, defended the Führerprinzip by name and
defended its value and its importance in ink.
In 1932 he wrote "The Concept of the Political",
which reduces politics to a single distinction, friend and enemy.
Then Hitler took power in January 1933, and within a breath the
anti-Nazi was a Nazi, a full-throated one, the crown jurist of the
Third Reich.
The political architecture of Nazism became the
subject of a book he wrote the very instant Nazism arrived, and he
was a Nazi about it into the bargain. Get over it.
The cleanest description of the whole structure
comes from the deputy Führer, Rudolf Hess, who called the
Führerprinzip unconditional authority downwards and total
responsibility upwards.
Everything that happened beneath an Unterführer belonged to him and reported up to his immediate Führer, who could punish or reward him for every triumph and every failure, and so the machine produced ferocious accountability from each Unterführer to his Überführer, all the way up the spine to Hitler, who had no one above him and stood as the last word and the highest law. Authority pressing down, responsibility flowing up.
That is the whole engine, and one can sanely
argue that it is a beautiful engine, if your taste runs to that kind
of ugliness.
Shareholder interests took a savage haircut, and the power shaved off them went straight to those appointed men.
Notice what is missing.
Shareholder interests never appear in the text of the law. They turn up only in the official explanation. The statute itself runs sixty-six pages of German and does not mention the interests of shareholders a single time; shareholders make their one cameo in the interpretation issued alongside it, off in a side room.
Kuntz continues, quoting a leading treatise on corporate law written by one of the men who was actually in the room when the thing was drafted:
The Vorstand became the Führer to the company, and the company came under the leader principle, and the Vorstand as Führer had to steer the corporation by the common good as Nazi principles defined it.
Skipping some material about how the clause played back in Weimar, Kuntz sets the whole thing down here:
There is the stakeholder model with its receipt attached.
That is what a government builds when it decides
to install the thing on purpose. The governing council eventually
fuses with the state, as it did in the German case, which was the
first genuine implementation of the model, unless you count the
Soviet Union, and the only reason the Soviet Union sits in a
footnote is that it contained exactly one corporation: itself.
All stakeholders, meaning the Volk and the Reich, organized and administered through the Führerprinzip, which meant the corporate governing board, the Vorstand, which in Russian I suppose we would have to call a corporate soviet, had to obey the leader principle and bend to the common good as the Nazi state understood it on behalf of the Volk and the Reich.
On paper the Volk and the Reich are merely key
stakeholders in every corporation. Through the leader principle they
become the primary stakeholders in fact, whatever the theory
pretends, and that gap between fact and theory is the exact spot
where, historically, everyone tends to die.
It looks familiar to us because we are living inside working examples of it, in communist China, in twenty-first century Dengist China, and in our own countries, on our own screens, in ESG and in the Sustainable Development Goals.
All the corporate theater that stamps Dylan
Mulvaney's face on a beer can, that makes drilling too expensive to
bother with, that installs DEI and ESG and sustainability officers
at ruinous cost into companies that never once asked for them, is
this same model in a party dress.
Common good is the load-bearing phrase; do not lose sight of it. Representative leaders, chosen for their capacity to embody the ideology, were to shepherd the common good into being.
Nazi, Soviet, same animal in different fur. The
boards that ran the corporations came under the leader principle and
under the priority of common good over individual gain, enforced by
state law in the German case, by absolute power and direct state
ownership in the Soviet case, and in our own case by the
manipulation of markets and stock values through ESG.
The primary stakeholders were the Reich, which is
to say the Nazi government itself, and the Volk, the people on whose
behalf it claimed to speak and toil, so what you really had was the
Reich, and then the Reich a second time, wearing the people as a
costume, which is what it always turns out to be under the costume.
Stakeholderism was in the air, and Hitler knew the Bolshevik machine intimately, so he understood the Soviet setup. Soviet means governing council. The distinction is that the Soviet system contained no independent corporations at all, because the state owned everything outright in the name of the people, while the Reich owned everything in the name of the Volk.
In the Soviet Union there was no pretense of
private ownership. In the National Socialist model after 1937 there
was a pretense of it, a stage-flat, which is the costume again in a
different scene.
Hitler may have borrowed the pretense of private
ownership from the Soviet Union. He may have borrowed it from
Mussolini, who was running the same arrangement in his corporatist
fascist model and describing it in exactly those terms. He may have
taken a little from each, why not, magpies are not fussy.
A technicality, a digression, and I am prone to both.
Argue if you like about whether the Nazis or the
Soviets first legislated the stakeholder system in the modern era.
It changes nothing. It is the same machine. The only real question
is whether you are willing to count corporations that are separate
from the state in a pretentious, cosmetic way as separate
corporations at all.
The headline is "The murky rise of Klaus Schwab's stakeholder capitalism and the WEF's Davos corporate plan," and the subhead asks whether the long battle against turning shareholder corporations into tools of public purpose is now lost, which is to say, whether we have already surrendered shareholder primacy to the stakeholder model.
Terence Corcoran did the reporting, so let
me use what he found.
The Forum would be at it again the following week, in the words of Klaus Schwab, the eighty-two-year-old German economist who founded it in 1973.
The existing shareholder model, the one that has
driven most of the world's economic progress for a century, needs to
go, and Schwab wants a change of mindset in its place, a move from
short-term to long-term thinking, from shareholder capitalism to
stakeholder responsibility, with ESG measured and folded into
corporate and governmental accountability.
An army of academics and consultants and
executives and politicians was already aboard the stakeholder
movement, and big change was coming, even though the whole concept
is riddled with black holes and dubious methods.
His real trick was the branding:
It is not capitalism, and there is nothing new in the concept.
Stakeholderism has risen and collapsed over and over across the last century, never quite overcoming the plain principle the U.S. Business Roundtable still stated as recently as 1997, that the paramount duty of directors is to serve the interests of the shareholders.
That principle is capitalism...
And the same Roundtable, by then headed by
Walmart's Doug McMillon, reversed itself in 2019 in a
statement everyone read as the abandonment of the shareholder model
for the stakeholder one.
Crude communism is low and mean, shares everything out flat, and delivers universal squalor to a round of applause. Champagne communism, the thing he actually describes, carries all the benefits of capitalism forward into an age where we act not out of the individual interest that built capitalism but as socialists.
The stakeholder movement is running the same
play, in the same order, for the same reason, dressed for a warmer
climate.
So if neoliberal shareholderism has been such a roaring success, why tear it out?
Cue Herbert Marcuse's "One-Dimensional Man" and
the criticism of capitalism from the 1960s onward. The complaint was
never that capitalism does not work. The complaint is that it is not
sustainable, which is the plank the degrowth movement still stands
on today: yes, it works, and it is all going to collapse anyway, so
what is the point.
That is part of it.
The deeper answer is sustainability, and running
alongside it, inclusivity, the promise that everybody has access and
everything works forever.
Read it in 2026 and it is not a theory, it is a
weather report. The object is to take private, profit-making
producers of goods and services and convert them into public
institutions that will serve various other public purposes in the
public interest. The labels are old friends: corporate social
responsibility, ESG, impact investing, sustainability. The freshly
minted ones are resilience and transition investing, the same
machine idling under a new hood.
The heaviest blow to Nader came from Friedman, whose famous 1970 essay, "The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase Profits," overshadowed the whole push for a federal charter, on the ground that an executive who taxes his shareholders and consumers to spend on social causes has quietly made himself a public employee, a civil servant, while still drawing a private salary.
Friedman's defense of the shareholders finished
Nader's call for national stakeholderism.
It would force every American corporation over a billion dollars in revenue to take a federal charter from a brand-new Office of United States Corporations at the Department of Commerce, and it would bind the directors to weigh the interests of all corporate stakeholders, employees and customers and shareholders and the communities where the company operates.
Which is the ESG model, wearing a senator's
pantsuit.
The point is that the Forum's origin story is a
fabrication, because the University of Calgary's Randall Morck,
editor of that history of corporate governance, sets the origin of
legalized stakeholderism in Germany and the National Socialist
government's Shareholders' Law of 1937, the law that, in Morck's
words, freed corporate managers and directors of their specific
fiduciary duty to shareholders and substituted a general duty to all
stakeholders.
And beyond Germany, in the early twentieth century, plenty of theorists and executives embraced the idea, among them Robert E. Wood, CEO of Sears in the thirties, who ranked the four parties to any business in order of importance and put the stockholders dead last, behind customers and employees and community, and Merrick Dodd, whose 1932 Harvard Law Review paper, "For Whom Are Corporate Managers Trustees?", argued for exactly this broadening of managerial responsibility and failed to catch on.
The current effort to end the era of shareholder
capitalism, in Biden's phrase, aims to undo the free-market
foundations of the thing.
McKinsey among them with a paper titled, without a flicker of shame, "The case for stakeholder capitalism," advising companies to start doing exactly what we already know they were told to start doing. Canada's biggest government pension funds, the CPP Investment Board and the Ontario Teachers', the country's largest shareholders, are behind the movement too, wanting to know how companies handle diversity and inclusion, human capital, climate change, social inequality, "systemic racism", and environmental threats.
And then Mark Carney walks back on, global stakeholder advocate and climate watchdog, very much the man of the hour, described as one of the leaders trying to rope the whole international investment community into imposing non-profit objectives on the companies it funds.
Carney has called on central bankers to hand
institutional shareholders the ammunition they need to force their
moral sentiments onto the managers of everyone's assets, until the
corporations are conveyors of the moral sentiments of government
pension managers and central bankers.
Scholarship on the purpose of corporations goes back centuries, but the current dominance of stakeholder theory in law and economics and politics is an affront to fundamental principles, because how can they call it capitalism when the result would be the destruction of capitalism as we know it.
Call it by its right name:
I want to double back to that sentence about Elizabeth Warren.
Nader's call for a federal charter was revived in
2018 by Senator Elizabeth Warren and her Accountable Capitalism Act
would drag every American corporation over a billion dollars onto
the stakeholder plan, employees and customers and shareholders and
the communities where they operate.
And I sat with that and wondered:
Carlson's version of the stakeholder model would
not be Warren's, but it would aim at the same target, the American
economic wreckage manufactured by the giant multinationals. The same
crosshairs, mounted on a different rifle.
It is the Guardian's Michael Massing, on
Tucker Carlson's moderate endorsement of Elizabeth Warren, under the
headline "Inequality
is so bad, even Fox News anchors decry capitalism," with
the line beneath it that in a recent monologue Carlson had sounded
like Bernie Sanders, and was not the only one, over a
pleasant photograph of Carlson filling the frame.
Ever since, Carlson had been pounded from left and right:
A proper who's who...
They fought over side issues, which is how our
media does its work, arguing in a ring around the thing and never
landing a punch on the thing, while the thing collects a mountain of
attention in entirely the wrong currency. Even Massing concedes that
the uproar reflects the messenger as much as the message.
Market capitalism, he said, at the expense of the family, the foundation of a healthy society, is not a religion but a tool, like a toaster or a staple gun, that it would be foolish to worship.
Republicans had to unlearn decades of
bumper-sticker talking points and corporate propaganda, and while
the libertarians would brand any deviation from market
fundamentalism a form of socialism, socialism, he warned, is exactly
what America will get unless a group of responsible leaders reforms
the economy in a way that protects normal people.
Larry Fink of BlackRock had already written to his CEOs that while the owners of capital had reaped enormous benefits, plenty of people faced low wages and inadequate retirement plans, feeding the anxiety and polarization loose in the world today, and had urged a new model of shareholder engagement, less about quarterly earnings and more about long-term value for employees and communities.
Henry Blodget, the former Wall Street
analyst who runs Business Insider, had said in a talk on better
capitalism that shareholder capitalism had turned America into a
nation of overlords and serfs, and that executives had forgotten one
of the reasons companies exist is for the people who work for them.
So Carlson comes out for the stakeholder model and floats a vote for Warren, and Shapiro plants his flag on shareholders.
And then Shapiro got upbraided by J. D. Vance, the author of "Hillbilly Elegy", who for those keeping score at home is presently the vice president of the United States.
The economy, Vance said, has not produced fewer dead children and more living parents where he lives, and he pointed at the opioid epidemic that has gutted so many communities, at Ohio and West Virginia and Kentucky where countless children grow up with parents in jail, incapacitated, or underground, a country with a higher GDP than a generation ago but few who would call themselves better off, and he warned that if conservatives cannot talk about people's real problems for fear of promoting victimhood, then they are fighting a battle they both deserve to lose and will.
The man who spent a whole book expressing deep
skepticism of government programs, Massing notes, seems to be
shifting. Shifting is a polite word for it.
On the FBI raid of Roger Stone's home, Carlson raged at Robert Mueller as a threat to democracy and an authoritarian nutcase even worse than Vladimir Putin, an interesting thing to say in 2019 given where the wind was blowing.
He mocked the press for panicking over Howard
Schultz's flirtation with a centrist independent run, sneered at
Gavin Newsom for trading the California governor's mansion for a
home in a mostly white neighborhood, and needled wealthy Democrats
for opposing Trump's wall while living behind high ones of their
own.
And it runs on in that vein. Massing lands here: in running down both immigrants and universal health care, Carlson had hosted a spokesman from a very conservative group that subscribes to the same free-market ideology he had denounced in the monologue, his show keeps transmitting Fox's blend of race-baiting and reality distortion through which it has done so much to poison the American mind, and Carlson himself is best described as a charter member of the same ruling class he indicted in the monologue for working so hard to divide and confuse the American people.
That is the Guardian for you. You can find the
same story in Slate and a dozen other places, and it repays the
reading.
And J. D. Vance arrives waving "Hillbilly Elegy"
and his own hard road to argue that shareholder primacy will not do
the job either, that Shapiro is wrong, and that we might need to
think about something in the neighborhood of the stakeholder model,
though, and this is the tell of the whole genre, he never once says
the words. He just tears at the model we have.
The title is "The case for common good capitalism," and I am going to keep translating it for you as the case for common good stakeholderism, because enforcing the common good part, out in the real world, requires a stakeholderist model to do the enforcing.
The subhead promises that dignified work and
strong families and strong communities are the key to civic and
economic well-being.
Leo held that the labor of the working class, its skill and its strength in the workshops of trade, is indispensable, and that justice demands the administration watch over the interests of the working classes so that the men who contribute so much to the community may share in the benefits they create.
Worker and consumer protection laws, and the
agencies that run them, are how we watch over those interests by the
administration, and I will note that we managed it without upending
the economy.
Let me stop him there, because the true test of any system of governance is its answer to the man who says no.
A business has the right to a profit, fine, and
it also carries an obligation to reinvest it according to whatever
Marco Rubio holds the common good to require, so picture the owner
who declines.
Now you reach for state power. You stand up a
federal charter system, and when the company grows large enough you
fold it into a scheme that distributes its resources and its means
of production. In the economy Leo described, Rubio says, workers and
businesses are not competitors over their share of limited resources
but partners in an effort that strengthens the entire nation, and
once you have installed government force to run that distribution
you have to decide how to pick winners and losers, and so you pick
them, chosen by the view of the common good held by some governing
council or committee, a stakeholder group running stakeholderism,
deciding who gets the distributions, how, when, from whom, and on
what terms.
The big corporations have become vehicles for
shareholders and banks to press claims on cash flow rather than
engines of productive innovation, and over the past forty years the
financial sector's share of corporate profit rose from about a tenth
to nearly a third, the share paid out to shareholders climbed three
hundred percent, and investment of those profits back into the
company's workers and future dropped by a fifth, while last year the
corporations on the S&P 500 spent more than a trillion dollars
buying back their own shares, the largest corporations in the world
collectively announcing they have nothing worth investing in.
We are not permitted to say he was a communist,
or a liberation theologian. Rubio piles Benedict on top too, on the
dominance of speculative financial flows detached from real
production, so there is a third pope on the stack now, and all of it
rests on Catholic distributist scaffolding, and it sounds like
Tucker Carlson, and it sounds like J. D. Vance.
Diagnosing that, he says, should be possible
across the spectrum, deciding what the government should do about it
is the core question of our politics, and we must start by rejecting
the false choice our politics has offered for three decades, because
the financialized economy is the product of past policy choices and
restoring the balance between the obligations and the rights of the
private sector and working Americans will take the attention of
today's lawmakers.
So the state walks in and forces the corporations to reinvest by hiring Americans specifically, into high-productivity, high-cost jobs.
There is the word we keep arriving at, no matter which road we take. Forces. Common good capitalism, he says, also means recognizing that what the market decides is most efficient may not be best for America.
Did you catch that one, DOGE...
The problem is ESG, which is a stakeholder model,
so his fix is a stakeholder model that forces businesses to behave a
certain way in order to counter a stakeholder model that is stopping
them from behaving that way in the first place. A stakeholder model
to cure a stakeholder model. Bring me leeches for the leeches.
So we are going to put a number on the economic
value of parenting your own children at home, in the manner of the
well-being economy the woke keep sketching, which is why he has
worked to expand the federal per-child tax credit and to create an
option for paid parental leave, on the principle that our nation
does not exist to serve the market, the market exists to serve our
nation. I do not believe either half of that.
Warm, all of it. But let me back up, because a
splinter has lodged in me.
Dignified versus better-paid, I suppose, and
either way you have the state standing over the businesses telling
them exactly what to do, and I promise you the dignified work turns
out to be well-compensated work, especially the kind that supposedly
knits communities back together.
He reaches back to Robert Kennedy in 1968, who
decried the cultural sickness that discourages initiative, paralyzes
will and action, and divides Americans from one another by their
age, their views, and the color of their skin, and 1968 was the year
of the cultural-Marxist run at a Marxist overthrow of the United
States and of enormous cultural subversion.
An America in which no one is held back by sex or
skin or ethnic origin is, he finishes, no longer just morally right
but a national imperative, because, in the words of the late
sociologist Robert Bellah, the transcendent goal of our
politics renders sacred our obligation to carry out God's will on
earth, the task each generation before us accepted, and now we must
decide whether to accept the challenge of our time and write the
next chapter in the story of the nation that changed the world.
Or maybe the real question is the one put to me at every gathering, always in a lowered voice:
Marco Rubio pushes the common good. J. D. Vance pushes the common good.
Joe Biden pushed the common good. Klaus
Schwab pushes the common good. And Tucker Carlson, which may explain
a great deal about the man, pushes the stakeholderist model, in
alignment, as he told us years ago, with Elizabeth Warren, who is
buried to the collarbone in the ESG left stakeholder model.
The entire post-liberal project is post-capitalist, on the left and on the right.
Post-capitalist economies, meaning economies that
have thrown out shareholder primacy, are stakeholderist economies,
whether they arrive dressed as a common good economy or a well-being
economy or any other outfit that has to be managed by somebody and
made to run in the name of something like the Volk.
And the right today, the men we have just heard from, Tucker Carlson and J. D. Vance and Marco Rubio, are building toward it too. Not all of the right, mind you; most of the right would be honestly alarmed to hear this said out loud.
But major players, and certainly the shitfluencer
right online, are pushing it through some virtue-centered
distributist model, Christian nationalist or otherwise.
It does not matter whether the values being
poured in belong to the People's Republic and its global ambitions,
the Belt and Road and the rest of the catalog. It does not matter
whether the hands on the wheel belong to the left or to stakeholder
capitalism at Davos, or to a virtue-driven, sometimes Christian
nationalist on the right. The paint is not the car.
And every one of these people shares a single rationale.
They believe they hold the correct model for
long-term greater-good success, or well-being, or whatever the word
is this season, and they conclude from that belief that they ought
to control how everyone else lives and operates in the economy with
their own private property, which under the model is no longer fully
private. In each case the stakeholders choose from among themselves
a set of unaccountable, unelected people, following the
Führerprinzip in one costume or another.
The first practically implemented version, in my view, was the Bolshevik model in the Soviet Union, which is a technical no because the Soviet Union held no corporations besides the state.
The first fully visible stakeholder model was
Nazi Germany in 1937, engineered to obliterate shareholder primacy
and liberal economic principle and to move into a post-liberal,
Reich-centered power structure in which the state could mobilize all
the corporations, in the name of the people, the Volk, to do
whatever it required, and could reach into companies that failed to
comply, whether Bayer or anyone else, up to and including dissolving
them, with a wide assortment of lesser controls besides.
Then Tucker Carlson lent it his support, and J.
D. Vance rode in to defend him, and Marco Rubio, after sitting on
Tucker's set a good many times to chew over these very questions,
stood up and gave a speech announcing that common good capitalism is
the answer.
NatCon is run by an Israeli Jew named Yoram
Hazony, whose endorsement rides on the front cover of "The Case
for Christian Nationalism" by Stephen Wolfe, the very book that says
out loud that Jews like Yoram Hazony would not be welcome to live
here without civil penalty under the author's own model. It does not
appear to trouble anyone, because Hazony is an Israeli who lives
most of the year in Israel. There is a bleak in the plumbing
somewhere when a Jew helps run part of the right, and I confess I
find it hilarious, and I do wonder why the same movement keeps
pushing the conspiracy theory that the world is secretly run by
Jews.
So on the one hand we have the National German
Workers' Party, which is what the Nazis called themselves, and on
the other we have the National Conservative American Workers' party,
which is of course a completely different animal, I am sure, in its
idea of a stakeholderist model operated through a government that
holds a fixed view of the common good and intends to enforce that
view on corporations by way of something very like a leader
principle, through one legal mechanism or another.
So watch stakeholderism, and study all its specimens, whether that is Mark Carney in Canada, or the World Economic Forum, or Joe Biden and the Democratic Party, or Tucker Carlson.
And if we hang the word woke on that road, the
way the Nazis hung it on their own slogan, Deutschland erwache,
Germany awake, Germany woke, then we have one more reason to think
the woke movements have earned every letter of its name.
|